NCAA Football News
The rain fell. And then it fell a bit harder. And then Michigan Stadium emptied as the skies opened, causing the football surface to look more pond than playing field.
For two hours and 24 minutes, Utah’s 26-10 lead over Brady Hoke’s Michigan Wolverines sat in the waiting room as water overtook the stadium. It was metaphoric—watching the grass slowly but surely give way to standing water—the kind of situation so strangely timed that it had to have been planned.
Status: ☔️ pic.twitter.com/oHM6bxgLEU— Michigan Football (@umichfootball) September 20, 2014
You knew that once play resumed, the outcome would not change. Utah would eventually win the game—and it did—and Mother Nature’s impressive bit of improv was simply postponing the inevitable. The game resumed with less than eight minutes remaining and Utah won 26-10. Just like you knew it would.
The inevitability won’t stop with Week 4, not when it comes to Hoke and his future at the program he still coaches. With this loss, the ones before it and the ones likely to follow, his fate is all but sealed.
Although it’s a cliched, cartoonish term, “on the hot seat” is actually a ruthless and unrelenting label that is rarely lifted. It is an unfair, unfortunate product of the lucrative business these coaches sign up for, and once you’re on it, you’re typically on it for good.
There are exceptions to the rule—look no further than Mississippi State’s Dan Mullen, who just delivered his most impressive victory to date—although these moments are few and far between.
When it rains, it pours. And although the Michigan Stadium turf is no longer under water, the skies are still ominous. Inevitability has set in.
Let’s move to brighter skies—unless you’re a Clemson or Cal fan—and highlight the players, moments and important Steve Addazio Vines of the week.
Offensive Player of the Week: Amari Cooper, Alabama
Other players across the country—some of which will undoubtedly be mentioned in the text to follow—delivered more stat-crazed performances in Week 4. But in terms of overall impact and competition faced, no player was more impressive than Alabama wideout Amari Cooper.
The stats were still awfully good. Cooper finished with 10 catches for 201 yards and three touchdowns while lining across from Florida cornerback Vernon Hargreaves III, arguably the conference’s top cover man.
Stats, however, won't do Cooper's recent run justice. It’s hard to put into words what he’s meant for a young quarterback, not just in this game but for the season. I know we don’t typically welcome wideouts into the Heisman conversation with open arms, but goodness does Cooper belong right now.
Dominant Defender: Zeek Bigger, ECU
ECU LB Zeek Bigger is named the Walter Camp Defensive Player-of-the-Week with 17 tackles and an interception TD. pic.twitter.com/vMyi0Z3gIk— InsideECUSports (@InsideECUSports) September 21, 2014
Before we celebrate a magnificent solo performance on the defensive side, let’s applaud this name. It’s as if the parents knew their son would play linebacker in college. (Oh, and he's rather good, too.)
Zeek Bigger, ECU linebacker, is a name built for a Hollywood football movie.
Bigger had himself a big day in ECU’s magnificent 70-41 beatdown of North Carolina, finishing with 17 tackles and a taking an interception back 46 yards for a touchdown. It was a score so lopsided you had to check it twice, and yep, it didn’t change. (Well, it did change. ECU's total kept going up.)
With Bigger’s performance, the junior now leads the nation in tackles (54). His name is also undefeated.
Video Game Box Score:
-Melvin Gordon fumbled. That might seem like a strange place to begin with video game box scores, although this fumble was special. More specifically, it was Gordon’s first-ever turnover at the college level and his first fumble lost in 322 carries. That’s impressive. Oh, and he ran for more than 250 yards and five touchdowns on just 13 carries. That's not bad, either.
-East Carolina is playing on novice, apparently. Or at least it seemed that way against North Carolina. The offense delivered 70 points, 789 (!!!) total yards and converted 12 of 17 third downs. Oh, and the Pirates also averaged 7.5 yards per rush on 46 carries. Goodness.
Anti-Video Game Box Score:
-Eastern Michigan finished the first half against Michigan State with one yard. That’s one less than two for those keeping track at home. Michigan State finished its first half with 320 yards (and 49 points) in the first. I hope you didn’t watch the second half and got some chores done instead.
-UConn ran a total of 36 plays against USF this week. This was not the first-half total; this was for the entire game. For perspective, Pittsburgh ran 18 plays on one drive against Iowa. Arizona ran 106 plays in its win against Cal. Running 36 plays—even in difficult weather—is ineptitude so unbelievable it should be given a parade.
Biggest Surprise: Jameis Winston Takes the Field
When Florida State head coach Jimbo Fisher saw his suspended quarterback dressed in uniform before the team’s game against Clemson, he offered up the same glare you give your cable and Internet company when you are put on hold.
It was a hint of exhaustion, a dash of disbelief and a solid helping of nerves before a critical game, one he would be without the player standing directly in front of him, helmet, pads and all. It came as a surprise to us, yet this was likely a miscommunication more than anything else.
That doesn’t take away from Fisher’s outstanding reaction, though.
I suppose “best” depends on your rooting interest, although the Cal-Arizona ending was nothing short of spectacular. And it wasn’t just the very end, although we’ll get to that shortly.
The fourth quarter alone gave us 50 points. After being down the entire game, Arizona bounced back and scored 36 points in the final 15 minutes to get within a field goal of winning.
Out of range, however, the Wildcats had to settle for a Hail Mary. Then this happened.
College football remains awesome, heartbreaking and unmistakably weird.
For the Highlight Reel
No, Clemson did not beat Florida State. But the Tigers delivered your early “Best Catch of the Year Featuring a Wide Receiver Wearing Only One Shoe” moment thanks to Mike Williams, who somehow caught this.
Losing a shoe wasn’t even the most impressive part of this play. The catch itself—along with the early, soccer-like slide—had everyone wondering what exactly just happened.
This is a quality consolation prize, right? (I’m sorry.)
If the College Football Playoff Started Today... (or Why I Hate Your Team)
Keep in mind that these are not projections. This is how are College Football Playoff would look if the season ended today.
Our playoff would also be 64 teams and played over the course of three months in the Bahamas, but that’s another conversation entirely. With that out of the way, here's where we stand.
4. Texas A&M
Five Leftovers to Chew on
1. Style points are so incredibly overrated, at least at this point of the year. As we look for the appropriate responses to Florida State and Oregon—two national championship favorites that enjoyed close calls for very different reasons—keep in mind how difficult the week-to-week grind can be for teams made up of 18-to-22-year-old kids. Stay alive, move on. It's that simple.
2. Mississippi State, as we have quickly learned, needs our utmost attention. Yes, the game against LSU got close (and weird) late, although the Bulldogs dominated this game, particularly at the line of scrimmage, throughout. Dak Prescott is emerging as a legitimate Heisman candidate, and Mississippi State might just be a Top 10 team.
3. Blake Sims throws a beautiful football. The Alabama quarterback is by no means a finished product, but there were a handful of “wow” throws included in his impressive performance against Florida. It’s amazing how much clarity that position suddenly has after being blasted and critiqued the entire offseason.
4. Kudos to Bo Pelini and Nebraska. Now, beating Miami (and a true freshman at QB) won’t suddenly solve all woes, but there is much to be excited about with the way this team is going about its business. Running back Ameer Abdullah is rolling and the defense—particularly the front seven—looks active. This was the start Pelini needed.
5. Even in a loss, West Virginia is light years better than where it was last year. The Mountaineers were unable to withstand Oklahoma’s late surge Saturday, although there’s no shame in that. Clint Trickett has been fabulous under Dana Holgorsen, and the defense is playing much better than we could have ever imagined. Nothing is a given with so much football to be played, but it certainly feels like Holgo’s hot seat has cooled.
Large Man Play of the Week
On his Michigan bio, Willie Henry is listed at 293 pounds. It is not everyday that men near 300 pounds find the end zone, and thus, we must celebrate Henry’s interception return with a hefty round of applause.September 20, 2014
Although he didn’t have to run far—seven yards, to be exact—it does not matter. It’s a touchdown, and it should be celebrated. Large men doing large things never becomes tiresome.
Mascot Save of The Week
Reveille, Texas A&M's loveable pup, was enjoying the game from a distance that was thought to be comfortable and out of range. Without warning, however, SMU wideout Der'rikk Thompson came barreling in that direction after an overthrow. We could make a joke about the SMU offense here, but we will refrain.
With Reveille suddenly in jeopardy, a brave A&M cadet stepped in and delivered the most impressive block of the afternoon.
SMU WR nearly runs into Texas A&M's mascot, but an A&M cadet was there to avert the collision: http://t.co/YP3u5yJ169— College GameDay (@CollegeGameDay) September 20, 2014
That’s what matters most here, not the SMU jokes. Although they are tempting.
Horrendous Flop of the Week
Is this were the NBA, Army linebacker Stephen Ricciardi would be fielding a call from the league office and a fine the size of Toyota Corolla. Needless to say, his attempt to draw a personal foul flag...did not work.
Behold Week 4’s most amazing, unsuccessful acting job and a full football field trying to figure out what just happened.
This Week in Coffins That Are Actually Team-Centric Tailgating Fixtures
Sure, you could ignore that unused coffin. Or, you could paint it yellow, throw on a decal, paint some stripes and build the necessary inserts to make it a cooler for your LSU tailgates.September 20, 2014
Yes, someone did that. No backstory is necessary, really. Behold the tailgating champions of the universe.
(Also, can I have one or four of those?)
That One Time a Center Forgot What He Was Supposed to Do
In 25 years, perhaps ESPN will produce a 30 for 30 on Eastern Michigan center Dwayne Brown and his incredible non-snap against Michigan State. The commercial will start something like this:
“What if I told you that a center in a college football game forgot to snap the ball before being belted and flagged for illegal procedure shortly after.”
Then this clip would play, and you would sprint to your DVR.
This Week in Steve Spurrier Vines
South Carolina almost lost to Vanderbilt, which is something I did not expect to type at any point over the next few years. But it happened.
After falling behind 14-0, the Gamecocks eventually kicked it into gear and ended up winning by two touchdowns. It was not comfortable, and it really never looked all that easy.
After the game, an unhappy, sweaty Steve Spurrier delivered expected hilarity on the effort. This Vine sums his thoughts up quite nicely, and if you'll excuse me, I have to watch this for the next few hours.
If you have time, watch his entire press conference. You will not regret it.
This Week in Year-Old Vines From a Head Coach Who Loves Saying “Dudes”
More than a year ago, Boston College head coach Steve Addazio decided it was time to upload some Vines, promote the school, and talk about “dudes.” So he did, and he hasn’t uploaded a Vine since.
Before he vanished, however, he gave us quick-hitting masterpieces like this.
And especially this.
Given Boston College’s recent win against unbeaten USC, it’s time for the Internet’s great crusader to return to his comfort place, a place where dudes can be celebrated with six-second clips and mild Internet cheers.
Come back, coach. We need you.
From the Peanut Gallery (Best Tweets of the Weekend)
Pat Fitzgerald used three (!!!) timeouts to ice Western Illinois' kicker. This game is a steaming pile of crap.— Chris Emma (@CEmma670) September 20, 2014
Halftime of EMU-Sparty. You kids want to see a dead body? pic.twitter.com/wgrrliBn4K— Vico (@ourhonordefend) September 20, 2014
🐢>🍊— Maryland Athletics (@umterps) September 20, 2014
Bold defensive strategy by the Gators pic.twitter.com/vAuHwzDopq— Cork Gaines (@CorkGaines) September 20, 2014
Live shot of Michigan athletics director Dave Brandon... pic.twitter.com/BtRvxZW1iF— Charles Robinson (@CharlesRobinson) September 20, 2014
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
The 2014 college football season is just four weeks old, yet the Big Ten is already down to its final two undefeated programs—Nebraska and Penn State. The Nittany Lions, fresh off of a win over Massachusetts and the NCAA's announcement that it is lifting their postseason ban, are suddenly thrust into a position where they not only control their own College Football Playoff destiny but perhaps also that of the Big Ten's.
We've heard plenty about how the Big Ten's rough non-conference record will keep the eventual conference champion out of the inaugural CFP come January. But will a 35-14 record really do that? Is it that much worse than the ACC's 33-10? Or the Big 12's 19-8?
Penn State is the true wild card in this situation. Perhaps the media has spent so long ignoring Penn State in the wake of the Sandusky scandal that it will provide the Nittany Lions an opportunity to fly in under the radar. Perhaps, just perhaps, the Nittany Lions, in the wake of an embarrassing and shameful chapter in their history, can become the saviors of the Big Ten's College Football Playoff hopes in 2014.
Unless otherwise noted, quotes or references to quotes were obtained firsthand by the writer.
Ohio State is replacing loads of talent from last year's team, including leading rusher Carlos Hyde, top receiver Corey Brown and first-team All-American linebacker Ryan Shazier.
Three new players have helped Urban Meyer replace those lost stars.
Coming off an open week, the No. 22 Buckeyes are preparing for their last nonconference matchup of the season—a home game against Cincinnati under the lights.
But through three games, these players have been a pleasant surprise for Buckeyes fans.
Ohio State needed its receivers to step up in the wake of Braxton Miller's season-ending shoulder injury. With players such as Devin Smith and Dontre Wilson on the perimeter, new quarterback J.T. Barrett had plenty of playmakers to ease his transition into the offense.
Michael Thomas, though, has been Barrett's top pass-catcher through three games.
Thomas—the nephew of legendary receiver Keyshawn Johnson—leads the Buckeyes in receptions (11), receiving yards (214) and touchdown receptions (four). He has recorded a touchdown in each of the Buckeyes' three games, and two of his scores have gone for more than 50 yards.
With the bevy of playmakers in Columbus, Meyer likes to rotate his receivers frequently. That's why Thomas knows he needs to make the most of his time on the field.
“I just know when a play comes, I’ve got to make it,” Thomas said, according to John Kampf of The Morning Journal. “You may not get as many chances. I just want to take advantage of my opportunities.”
The Buckeyes needed a big boost at linebacker when Shazier opted out of his senior season in favor of the NFL draft. The unit was Meyer's top defensive concern a season ago, and without its best player, the group needed some young players to step up.
Redshirt freshman Darron Lee has answered the call.
The former 3-star prospect played quarterback and safety in high school, but he bulked up last year and surged in spring practice to lock down one of Ohio State's outside linebacker positions. And so far this season, he's playing inspired football.
Lee is fifth among Buckeyes with 17 tackles, but he's tied with Joey Bosa for the team lead in tackles for loss with five. His fumble recovery and 61-yard touchdown return against Navy sparked an Ohio State rally in the season opener, and his all-around play and energy have given the Buckeyes defense new life.
“He probably has one of the most fiery personalities on the team," fellow linebacker Joshua Perry said, according to Bill Rabinowitz of The Columbus Dispatch. "He’s really upbeat. He’s bouncing around all the time. He’s loud. He’s got a lot of juice and energy.
"He loves picking guys up and being a catalyst.”
Meyer is hoping Lee continues to surge alongside an improving defense.
Ezekiel Elliott appeared to be next in line with Hyde's departure—destined for big things as Ohio State's featured running back.
While that could still come to fruition, the Buckeyes have split carries to showcase their deep stable of ball-carriers. And so far, freshman Curtis Samuel has been the most productive.
Samuel and Elliott have the same number of carries (27), but the freshman is averaging a full yard more per carry. Both have rushed for two touchdowns and proved themselves as reliable pass-catchers.
Samuel has just looked better at times. He's leading the team with 171 rushing yards and has the long run of the season for the Buckeyes (26 yards). Meyer knows he's just scratching the surface.
David Regimbal covers Ohio State football for Bleacher Report. Follow him on Twitter @davidreg412.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
Week 4 looked great on paper. It was even better on the field.
The fun started Thursday evening (Auburn's miraculous escape at Kansas State) and continued through the wee hours of Sunday morning (Arizona's really miraculous Hail Mary to beat Cal), and much of what happened in between was just as good. It was the best week of a season where none have been bad.
Predictably, a week with so many good games meant a number of striking individual performances. Constructing this list is never easy, but it is rarely as hard as it was for Week 4.
Ultimately—as always—the main criteria went beyond raw statistics. Big numbers matter, but they matter more against a good opponent than a bad one. They also matter more when they take place in clutch game situations, something that had a big effect on the Week 4 first-team defense (see: defensive tackle and cornerback).
Chime in below and let me know whom I missed.
In 2006, there was a debate over whether Michigan or Florida should play Ohio State in the BCS championship game, even though the Wolverines were just coming off a loss to the Buckeyes to end the season.
At the time, it sparked initial comments from then-Florida coach Urban Meyer and then-Michigan coach Lloyd Carr about potentially starting a playoff to solve the conundrum:
As Florida padded its resume, second-year coach Meyer became very vocal about getting a chance to play Ohio State, especially when it appeared the Gators would be left out.
He called for a playoff and suggested the BCS should be imploded if the SEC champ again was left out of the championship game -- the way undefeated Auburn was in 2004.
"It's an imperfect system," Meyer said Sunday. "If you want a true national championship, the only way to do it is on the field.
Carr agreed: "I hope one day we have a system where all the issues are decided on the field."
How things have changed in eight years.
Now officially in the College Football Playoff era, neither Michigan nor Florida look ready to compete for a spot in the four-team field any time soon.
The Wolverines are coming off a 26-10 loss at home to Utah and have yet to score a touchdown against a Power Five opponent this season (h/t Nicole Auerbach, USA Today). Florida was no match for Alabama in a 42-21 loss. Both programs were simply outclassed.
So how did two perennial powers fall from the top of the college football mountain?
Nearly nine months after Florida surpassed Michigan for the chance to play the Buckeyes, the Wolverines again were surpassed on the field in the greatest college football stunner to date: a 34-32 season-opening loss to Appalachian State.
In addition to igniting the wackiest season in recent college football memory—check out this top 25 from midseason—it marked the final months of the Carr era in Ann Arbor.
An 8-4 regular season with yet another loss to Ohio State was the end, and Carr's final game came against Florida, of all teams, in a Capital One Bowl win.
As Michigan tried to fix its problems, however, it only prolonged them. The university hired Rich Rodriguez from West Virginia, an offensive mastermind with a history in the zone-read. Rodriguez didn't have ties to the program and never got off to a smooth start, as Mark Snyder of the Detroit Free Press chronicled.
From his perspective, Michigan suffered from an entitlement issue. Here's what Rodriguez said in 2013 in an interview with Matt Hayes of the Sporting News:
We had some guys committed at Michigan, but we had others that weren’t. Some guys felt a sense of entitlement. The name on the chest, and 'I’ve already arrived.' The Chad Hennes and the Jake Longs put the work in and succeeded before us, and guys behind them thought they were entitled to the same status but hadn’t proved anything.
Regardless, an NCAA inquiry into violations over practice time and poor on-field results put the heat on Rodriguez. He was never able to have a defense that matched his offense and was let go after a Gator Bowl loss to Mississippi State in 2011 with a 15-22 overall record in three seasons.
Michigan then hired San Diego State coach Brady Hoke, a former Wolverines assistant. Things appeared to be headed in the right direction when Michigan went 11-2, topped off with a Sugar Bowl victory over Virginia Tech, in Hoke's first year in 2011.
Things have gone downhill ever since.
Michigan hasn't won more than eight games in a season with Hoke at the helm, and it was announced in January that offensive coordinator Al Borges would not be back for the 2014 season.
In addition to coaching turnover, Michigan's inability to develop talent has been its biggest problem. The Wolverines haven't had more than three players taken in each NFL draft since 2008.
Amazingly, Michigan had two offensive linemen taken in the '14 draft—Taylor Lewan and Michael Schofield—but ranked 104th nationally in rushing offense, per cfbstats.com.
The offense hasn't looked any better under first-year OC Doug Nussmeier. Now 2-2, Hoke is reaching near rock bottom, according to Nick Baumgardner of mlive.com.
How long it takes Hoke to get Michigan out of its hole, if he can at all, remains to be seen.
As Matt Hinton of Grantland writes, "When Hoke says 'This is Michigan' in 2014, the distance between the Michigan in his mind and the Michigan he’s selling to teenagers who were newborns when the Wolverines last wore the crown has never been greater."
Florida had success after the 2006 season. In fact, two years later, it won a national championship with Meyer. But two years after that, the Gators went 8-5 and Meyer stepped down from his position to spend more time with his family.
That decision came one year after Meyer retired, briefly before changing his mind, for health reasons.
Florida hired Texas defensive coordinator Will Muschamp, considered to be a rising star in the business. But things have been troublesome for Muschamp since becoming the head coach.
Mainly, the Gators, previously an offensive juggernaut under Meyer, haven't finished in the top 70 in scoring offense since Muschamp's arrival, per cfbstats.com. Things hit a low point in 2013 during a disastrous 4-8 campaign in which Florida 113th in points scored.
Whereas Michigan had no problem scoring but couldn't stop anyone under Rodriguez, Florida has had the opposite problem with Muschamp.
Of course, there's been massive turnover at the offensive coordinator position. Former Notre Dame and current Kansas head coach Charlie Weis was the Gators' play caller for one year. Former Boise State offensive coordinator Brent Pease never got things going in his two years (2012-13), either.
This past offseason, Muschamp hired Duke offensive coordinator Kurt Roper to repair the damage. However, following a 42-21 loss to Alabama, it's clear Roper still has a lot of work to do, specifically with quarterback Jeff Driskel.
But, unlike Michigan as of late, getting NFL-caliber players through the program hasn't been as big of a problem.
In 2013, eight players were drafted into the pros. However, Muschamp has hinted that perhaps Meyer left the program in a bad situation, which Muschamp has had to build back up. From Mike Bianchi of the Orlando Sentinel:
To Muschamp's credit, he never blamed Meyer for a roster that was bereft of experience, depth and discipline in Year 1, although he did hint that there were some issues. Meyer's disciplinary and player-arrest record at UF were abysmal, and Muschamp had to clean out some of the character problems. That left him a roster of only 71 scholarship players last season — 14 below the NCAA limit.
If Muschamp inherited a problem, he certainly hasn't found a solution yet. Muschamp's defense, normally solid, has allowed 818 pass yards over the last two games.
Is Muschamp on the hot seat? He's definitely going to have to get Florida back to a bowl game to even have a chance of eliminating that conversation.
For blue bloods like Michigan and Florida, the fall from the top rung to mediocrity has been surprising. Each took their separate routes, but share common problems: underdeveloped talent, poor coaching hires and/or turnover and the rise of surrounding programs.
Florida, for example, is now competing head-to-head with programs like South Carolina. Michigan, meanwhile, has lost five of its last six meetings with Michigan State. Not surprisingly, Steve Spurrier (South Carolina) and Mark Dantonio (Michigan State) are considered some of the best coaches in the business.
Michigan and Florida are getting out-coached and out-played. The instability surrounding each program plays a role, but in theory, both should be able to rebound quickly given their resources.
That's proving to be more difficult than it originally seemed.
Ben Kercheval is a lead writer for college football. All quotes cited unless obtained firsthand.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
The Texas A&M football team improved its record to 4-0 with a 58-6 victory over SMU. The Aggies will take on the 3-1 Arkansas Razorbacks on Saturday at AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas.
The Aggies are ranked No. 7 in the coaches poll. Arkansas is out to prove that it is a better team than the 2013 version that lost all eight of its conference games after going 3-1 in non-conference play.
This game will showcase diverging theories on offense, with the Aggies' no-huddle spread versus the Razorbacks plodding rushing game. Texas A&M wants to run as many offensive plays as possible in order to wear a defense out.
Arkansas wants to grind out yardage with the running game, control the clock and wear the defense down by physically overpowering them.
The Aggies are looking to improve to 2-0 in the SEC and move into contention for the SEC title. The Razorbacks are trying to even their conference record and remind the world that this is not a repeat of 2013.
This is a look at how the Aggies and Razorbacks match up.
Mississippi State head coach Dan Mullen struggled for a signature win throughout the first few years of his tenure as the Bulldogs' head coach. He entered Saturday night's matchup with LSU with a 2-22 record against ranked opponents, with both of those wins coming against teams that were average at best (Ole Miss 2009, Florida 2010).
That third win against ranked competition resonated like a clap of thunder that was a little too close for comfort.
The Bulldogs manhandled then-No. 8 LSU in a 34-29 victory in Death Valley on Saturday night, notching the biggest win of his Mississippi State career. If the previous wins over ranked opponents were considered "signature wins," this one was written in ink, paint and etched in stone.
Don't be fooled by the score. Mississippi State treated LSU like a cupcake in a paycheck game for the majority of the night, and then survived a late charge led mostly by LSU's backups.
This begs the question, what does the future hold for Mullen?
It should include more taxes being paid to the city of Starkville, Mississippi, because the Bulldogs and Mullen are a perfect fit.
I'll admit, I was wrong about Mullen.
Up until late last season, he had done a lot to raise the floor of the program but hadn't really done much to impact the ceiling. Sure, four straight bowl games was nice, but there wasn't much to indicate the possibility of upward mobility for the program.
There is now.
Mississippi State went into one of the most hostile environments in college football, played his brand of football and flat out whipped the typically-physical Tigers.
There have been suitors for Mullen in the past.
He was linked to the Penn State job in late 2011, according to Sports Illustrated, and Miami was turned off by Mullen before it hired Al Golden after the 2010 season, according to The Miami Herald (via SportsByBrooks.com).
What's done is done, though, and Mullen's future looks incredibly bright in Starkville.
Why does that matter?
If Mullen is going to be linked to any job after this season, it'll likely be Florida. He won two national championships as the offensive coordinator of the Gators in 2006 and 2008 and is familiar with the recruiting territory. Plus, Muschamp isn't doing his hot seat any favors by combining a suddenly putrid defense with a consistently woeful offense.
Would the Florida job really be worth leaving Starkville for? At this point, no.
The pay would be roughly the same, and if Florida started tossing cash at Mullen's front door, Mississippi State would have no problem matching it now that the SEC has what amounts to its own version of a mint known as the "SEC Network."
Sure, the immediate upside would be great. After all, Florida has a recruiting base that is second to none in college football. What Florida lacks, though, is job stability.
Mullen has now established that in Starkville, which is a rarity for the coaching profession.
Saturday night proved that while the journey takes a little while longer at a program like Mississippi State, the potential still exists to be great—even in the SEC West. Mullen already walked down that path, built the program the way he wanted to and proved that it works.
There's no reason to leave now. It's just getting good.
Barrett Sallee is the lead SEC college football writer and video analyst for Bleacher Report, as well as a co-host of the CFB Hangover on Bleacher Report Radio (Sundays, 9-11 a.m. ET) on Sirius 93, XM 208.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
If you can believe it, we're approaching one month into the college football season.
And the B/R freshmen power rankings are chugging along, like a train of high ceilings, raw talent and untapped potential.
The freshmen on this list didn't technically have to start—as in, they didn't have to be the first player on the field at their respective position—but they did have to play at least a complementary or rotational role with at least one recordable stat.
These rankings are also subject to change from week to week depending on who shines.
So which freshmen stood out in Week 3? Which ones had the most jaw-dropping highlights? Which ones underwhelmed? The answers are in the list below.
Oklahoma running back Samaje Perine. With Keith Ford sidelined with an ankle injury, the freshman running back helped the Sooners grind out a 45-33 victory against West Virginia. Perine, unofficially known now as Optimus Perine, carried the ball 34 times for 242 yards and four touchdowns.
Of course, the Sooners did a tremendous job blocking up front, but opposing defenses shouldn't want anything to do with the 5'11", 243-pound freshman. He's a wrecking ball.
How do you not go with Anu Solomon's 47-yard Hail Mary to Austin Hill in Arizona's wild 49-45 come-from-behind stunner over Cal?
Solomon had a night he may never replicate again with 73 pass attempts for 520 yards and five touchdowns. Considering the Wildcats had to score 36 fourth-quarter points, it's no surprise Solomon had to throw the ball a ton.
Still, what an incredible play to cap off a wild Week 4.
Ohio linebacker Quentin Poling. Yeah, this is an off-the-radar pick, and the Bobcats have been so-so at best this year. But Poling is quietly starting to rack up some eye-catching stats.
The redshirt freshman had three interceptions in 36-24 win over Idaho, returning them for a total of 77 yards. He also leads the team in tackles with 34.
Poling won't get a lot of publicity because of the team he plays for, so might as well give him a little love while we can.
Technically, Leonard Fournette led LSU with seven carries for 38 yards in Saturday's 34-29 loss to Mississippi State. He had a long run of 20 yards, but he was otherwise quiet. Then again, LSU was playing from behind. Running the ball isn't really an option there.
Fournette is churning out a decent enough year with 200 yards through four games, but with SEC play underway, the Tigers have been a so-so rushing team. Fournette is quickly falling out of the spotlight.
Ben Kercheval is a lead writer for college football.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
Four weeks are in the books, and the once-murky SEC quarterback picture has come into focus.
Remember when Texas A&M had a challenge replacing former quarterback Johnny Manziel? That seems like a decade ago.
Remember Alabama's "quarterback controversy?" Blake Sims ended that the moment he stepped foot off the bus at the Georgia Dome for the season opener.
Remember when Jeff Driskel was set to thrive in Kurt Roper's hurry-up, no-huddle offense? That hasn't really happened yet.
Stars have emerged, others have fallen off and several SEC veterans have elevated their play through the first four weeks. We re-rank the SEC starting quarterbacks in this slideshow.
After a weekend of close calls for top teams, one major upset and the usual unpredictability and excitement that college football brings, both the Amway coaches poll and Associated Press poll were released Sunday.
And, as always, there were plenty of strong opinions to follow.
But first, let's take a look at the polls. Here's the AP poll:
And here is the coaches poll:
The biggest storyline this week was arguably Mississippi State jumping into the rankings, as Ralph D. Russo of The Associated Press noted:
And Knox Bardeen of Fox Sports South was happy to see the team also pop up in the coaches poll:
Meanwhile, Hugh Kellenberger of The Jackson Clarion-Ledger noted that a bit of history was made Sunday:
Of course, the SEC West had a pretty darn good day in both polls. Stewart Mandel of Fox Sports notes its big performance in the AP poll:
Meanwhile, former Alabama quarterback and current SEC Network broadcaster Greg McElroy noted its strong showing in the coaches poll:
But enough of the SEC West love. While there was never bound to be much movement near the top of the rankings outside of LSU, there were a few surprises nonetheless. John Coon of The Associated Press noted one:
And Jon Solomon of CBS Sports pointed out a few more:
The last tweet points out one of the stranger instances that always seem to pop up on a yearly basis: Team A beats Team B and each team has the same amount of losses, but Team B is ranked higher. Huh? How does that work?
Folks making the polls will claim it's a look at an overall resume. Perhaps. Or maybe teams are always punished that lose later in the season than teams that lose early. That has always felt closer to the truth.
The top of both sets of rankings seems likely to remain pretty much the same next week, barring a major upset. However, a few games—namely UCLA facing Arizona State and Missouri taking on South Carolina—could shake things up a little further down.
As always, it should be another fun week of action.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
Week 4 has come and gone, and we inch ever closer to the first College Football Playoff. There's still a long way to go in the season, but contenders are starting to take shape.
Florida State and Oregon survived and advanced against Clemson and Washington State, respectively. Auburn fended off Kansas State in one of the more intriguing nonconference matchups of the season. Alabama hosed Florida despite being bit by the turnover bug, and Oklahoma powered past West Virginia on the road.
Now, The Associated Press, USA Today and Bleacher Report have the difficult task of ranking the Top 25 teams. The Top 10 feels set for the most part, but how does the top half look? Do voters keep Florida State at No. 1 because it keeps winning? How much does a close win at Washington State hurt Oregon?
These are just some of the questions voters have to answer.
How did the polls look? Which teams are the hits and which are the misses? The answers are in the following slides.
For the second straight week, a college football Saturday that looked straightforward proved anything but. Top 10 teams went down in flames, the entire Top Five was scared to varying degrees and another potential monster in the SEC West emerged.
At the top, Florida State and Oregon were sweating bullets down to the final minutes. A key defensive stop and a 12-yard Karlos Williams run gave the Seminoles an overtime victory against Clemson, while not long later Oregon was going on a 3:34 drive to ice the final moments of a 38-31 win over Washington State.
That, of course, came a couple of days after Auburn had its own game-icing drive to take down Kansas State in Manhattan. Alabama and Oklahoma were both scared deep into the third quarter of their matchups with Florida and West Virginia, respectively, but were able to prevail by double digits.
What does this mean? Well, basically, all that excitement was for nothing. The top of college football's available polls remains the same, and the poll that actually matters is still weeks from being decided. The basic takeaway from Week 4 is that LSU will almost certainly not be making a College Football Playoff appearance.
Everything else? Still to be decided. With that in mind, let's run a postmortem on the day that was for the nation's top four teams.
No. 1 Florida State
Sometimes, Florida State makes games look too easy. The athletes overwhelm even the best competition, with defenders swarming to the point of attack and skill-position guys all looking like they run 1.2-second 40-yard dashes. It's then at times difficult to gauge the value of Jameis Winston—an undoubtedly talented quarterback who gets a ton of time to throw and has awesome running backs and wide receivers around him.
Saturday night may have been the best possible evidence of Jameis' on-field awesomeness. Playing without the Heisman winner, who was suspended for Saturday's game after making lewd comments on campus, the Florida State offense sputtered.
Backup Sean Maguire was wildly inaccurate in the first half and wildly dangerous in the second, highlighted by two fourth-quarter interceptions. A good chunk of Maguire's 305 yards came on a 74-yard touchdown pass to Rashad Greene, who had the benefit of not having a defender within five yards of him. Strip away that play, and Maguire barely averaged more than six yards per attempt.
Greene's touchdown and two missed field goals by Clemson's Ammon Lakip wound up being the Seminoles' savior. Afraid Lakip would miss another kick, Clemson coach Dabo Swinney went for a 4th-and-short in overtime and failed. Two plays later, Karlos Williams was running in from 12 yards out to give Florida State the 23-17 win.
Meeting Williams in the end zone was Winston, who bum-rushed the field the second his running back hit paydirt.
"(Winston) told me he's proud of me," Williams told reporters after the game. "He's a great leader. He did something you really don't see in a lot of starting quarterbacks, which is rally behind the backup."
With Winston back in the lineup, the Seminoles shouldn't have many problems for the next month. They go on the road to North Carolina State next week before taking on Wake Forest and Syracuse. The Wolfpack are 4-0 but have spent the early part of their schedule on a cupcake-mashing spree. Pollsters might be turned off a bit by Winston's actions, but there's no reason to worry until Oct. 18's matchup with Notre Dame.
No. 2 Oregon
Marcus Mariota is probably your Heisman trophy favorite through the first four weeks. The Oregon signal-caller was essentially solely responsible for Saturday night's close win in Pullman, completing 21 of 25 passes for 329 yards and five touchdowns. Despite being sacked seven times (sacks count as negative rushing yards), Mariota also added 58 yards on the ground.
Like his sophomore campaign, Mariota's most impressive feat remains his decision-making. He is yet to throw an interception in 95 attempts. Add in the whole 1,135 yards, 11 touchdowns and 74 percent completion rate thing, and you have an inhuman life form sent from another planet to embarrass us mere mortals.
"He did a great job of rattling the defense in the second half," Oregon coach Mark Helfrich told reporters. "The guy is special."
The special guy was nearly undone by a defense that allowed 436 yards and four touchdowns to Washington State quarterback Connor Halliday. The Cougars were never behind by more than a touchdown and might have won the game had it not been for two lost fumbles.
As the schedule difficulty ratchets up, Oregon might have issues in its secondary. Halliday's performance gave Ducks fans deja vu from Connor Cook's first half in the Ducks' win over Michigan State.
Hmm, come to think of it, maybe Oregon just can't defend the pass against people named Connor. Just saying, Arizona; maybe it's time for the Connor Brewer era to begin under center. Anu Solomon is great and all but is he REALLY good enough to overcome the droves of evidence we have indicating a #ConnorCurse? [Kanye shrug]
(Psst, Oregon will be fine. Mariota is awesome.)
No. 3 Alabama
It took Blake Sims five years to get his chance in Tuscaloosa. He's sure taking advantage of it. The Alabama quarterback was sensational Saturday, throwing for 445 yards and four touchdowns as the Crimson Tide scored the final 21 points of their 42-21 win over Florida.
Save for a brief injury reprieve, in which backup Jake Coker threw a touchdown to Amari Cooper, Sims was the best player on the field. His gaudy yardage total came on a somewhat reserved 33 attempts, and the senior showed off his legs on multiple occasions.
"I didn't think it was possible," Sims told reporters of passing for 400 yards at Alabama. "I just try to take what I take and what the defense gives me, and just try to trust my guys that they're going to be there."
Saturday's game may have been the clearest sign yet that this is not a typical Nick Saban Alabama team. Under offensive coordinator Lane Kiffin, the Tide have noticeably had more success through the air this season. Sims has thrown for 1,091 yards and eight touchdowns against only two interceptions, completing nearly three quarters of his passes.
Cooper, should he stay healthy, looks to be headed for the Biletnikoff Award. His 43 receptions are nearly four times more than any other Alabama receiver. DeAndrew White, who has caught 12 passes, and Christion Jones, who has 10, are the only other players even in double digits.
The Tide haven't had a real defensive test this season outside West Virginia—all three Florida touchdowns came as the result of Alabama turnovers; don't get it twisted—so it'll be interesting to see how they handle a road trip to Ole Miss in two weeks. The Rebels are eighth nationally in passing yards per game and have the defensive talent to match up with Alabama's athletes defensively.
Given Clint Trickett's success against the Tide in August, Bo Wallace may just find enough holes to help Ole Miss pull off the shocker. Then again, a two-week break for Nick Saban is typically a death sentence for his opponent.
No. 4 Oklahoma
Speaking of Mr. Trickett, he had quite the game against Oklahoma's secondary Saturday night. The West Virginia quarterback threw for 376 yards and two touchdowns, but his two interceptions both came in Oklahoma territory and wound up leading to Samaje Perine touchdown runs. Trickett's second pick came immediately after one from Travis Knight that gave West Virginia a short field with a chance to take the lead.
In the end, the Sooners wound up stretching their lead to 45-27 before a meaningless late touchdown finalized the score at 45-33. Perine rushed for 242 yards and four touchdowns on his 34 carries, perhaps giving himself an edge for a workhorse load the remainder of the season.
"You know about how powerful and strong he is, but he has great vision," Oklahoma coach Bob Stoops told reporters. "He has great stamina and is a very conditioned athlete. He works hard at his conditioning."
Perine had been sharing carries with Keith Ford and Alex Ross. Ford sat out Saturday, and his status for the next couple weeks is uncertain due to a fracture in his right leg. A true freshman, Perine was the less touted of Stoops' 2014 recruits. Joe Mixon was widely viewed as one of the two best high school running backs in the country with Leonard Fournette, but Mixon's season-long suspension after assaulting a woman opened the door for Perine to shine.
Oklahoma's biggest concerns remain at quarterback. Trevor Knight is slightly improved from his freshman season form but still battles with accuracy issues and poor decision-making. Knight, at this point, does not look like a steady enough quarterback to lead an undefeated team into the playoff.
We're going to get a good idea of the makeup for this Oklahoma team soon. The Sooners travel to TCU in two weeks in what should be a closer-than-advertised contest and then have games against Texas and Kansas State before their next bye. If they get through all three games unscathed, then maybe this is a title contender after all.
Follow Tyler Conway (@tylerconway22) on Twitter
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
Week 4 of the 2014 college football season may have been better described as Survival Saturday. Each of the nation's Top Five teams were in action and extended their respective unbeaten streaks. Very few (if any) of them can feel too great about how they played, though.
Florida State, Oregon and Auburn escaped with one-touchdown victories. Alabama and Oklahoma stretched their wins to the double digits but were sweating bullets deep into the second half.
With none of the nation's best separating themselves, The Associated Press rankings for Week 5 remain in an inert state. The Seminoles remain atop the rankings after their overtime win against Clemson, followed by Oregon, Alabama, Oklahoma and Auburn, respectively.
Here's a look at how the rest of the Top 25 played out, along with Bleacher Report's official Top 25:
Despite escaping the fierce fight against Clemson, Florida State's near-loss was by far the most talked-about game of the day. The Seminoles were forced to play without Heisman winner Jameis Winston, who was suspended for Saturday's game after shouting obscenities in the student union.
Backup Sean Maguire struggled for most of the game, battling accuracy issues and looking overwhelmed by the big stage. It wasn't until Florida State's back was planted firmly against the wall that he finally came through with a crucial play. Maguire's 74-yard strike to Rashad Greene tied the game at 17-17 with six minutes remaining and eventually became the score that forced overtime.
After Clemson, which saw kicker Ammon Lakip miss two critical field goals, went for it on fourth down and failed in the extra session, Karlos Williams did the rest of the work. A 13-yard gain on first down was followed by a 12-yard scamper that extended the Seminoles' winning streak to 19. Winston was one of the first people to rush the field in celebration.
"(Winston) told me he's proud of me," Williams told reporters after the game, per the Associated Press, via ESPN.com. "He's a great leader. He did something you really don't see in a lot of starting quarterbacks, which is rally behind the backup."
As Florida State was escaping, Oregon was experiencing quite a scare, too. Washington State was able to keep up with the Ducks' high-powered offense with a banner outing of its own, led by 436 yards and four touchdowns from quarterback Connor Halliday. The Cougars held a lead early and were never down more than a touchdown.
Oregon forced a fourth-down stop deep inside its own territory and then ran out the final 3:34 with an eight-play drive to earn the 38-31 win. Heisman contender Marcus Mariota threw for 329 yards and five touchdowns, adding 58 yards on the ground.
"He did a great job of rattling the defense in the second half," Oregon coach Mark Helfrich told reporters, per the Associated Press, via ESPN.com. "The guy is special."
The divergent evenings of Mariota and Winston, expected to be the top two quarterbacks off the board in next year's draft, are no doubt being talked about in NFL front offices. ESPN's Mel Kiper Jr. (subscription required) dropped Winston from third to 25th on his most recent big board; Mariota is now alone at the top.
Also trending in opposite directions are SEC rivals Alabama and LSU, with one able to escape a scare from a conference foe and the other not so much. Alabama's 42-21 win over Florida was much closer than the score indicates. The Gators tied the score at 21-21 early in the third quarter; the Tide didn't take their final lead of the game until there were a little over 20 minutes remaining.
But Derrick Henry's three-yard touchdown began a 21-0 run that looked like the game most expected. Amari Cooper scored the final two touchdowns as part of a 10-catch, 201-yard day. Quarterback Blake Sims threw for 445 yards and four touchdowns.
Likewise, LSU managed some rapid second-half scoring against Mississippi State. Unfortunately for the Tigers, it came as part of a failed comeback bid. The Tigers, down 34-10 early in the fourth, reeled off three straight touchdowns but couldn't convert the necessary two-point conversions. Their last drive stalled with a Will Redmond interception of Brandon Harris' Hail Mary attempt as time expired.
Mississippi State quarterback Dak Prescott had 373 total yards (268 passing, 105 rushing) and three touchdowns, including two plays of 50-plus yards in the second quarter. Running back Josh Robinson needed only 16 carries to gain his 197 yards.
The win was Mississippi State's first in Baton Rouge in nearly a quarter-century.
"It's not necessarily just the players. I'm putting first of all the responsibility on me," LSU head coach Les Milestold reporters, per the Associated Press, via ESPN.com. "I know our guys on our team expect more from themselves...They're stung and it's not something that they enjoyed."
Miles' team moves down from No. 8 to No. 17. Mississippi State, meanwhile, moves into the rankings at No. 14 as it prepares for Texas A&M in two weeks. The Bulldogs then host Auburn on Oct. 11, rounding out a three-game gauntlet featuring Top 10 opponents—all from the SEC West.
The only other Top 25 team to fall to an unranked opponent also came from the SEC. Missouri's hot offensive start against also-rans proved to be a bit of fool's gold, as Indiana rushed for 241 yards in a 31-27 upset in Columbia. D'Angelo Roberts scampered in for the game-winning touchdown with 22 seconds remaining.
According to ESPN Stats & Info, the win was only Indiana's fourth in program history against a nonconference AP Top 25 team on the road. This same Hoosiers team lost on the road in Bowling Green last week—not a great sign for a Missouri squad that begins its SEC schedule in South Carolina next Saturday.
The Tigers are one of two teams to drop out of the rankings, the other being Clemson. Replacing them are Mississippi State and East Carolina, which found its latest upset victim Saturday in North Carolina. Led by quarterback Shane Carden, the Pirates have had three consecutive strong showings against Big Five schools. They look like a favorite in the American Athletic Conference.
Follow Tyler Conway (@tylerconway22) on Twitter
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
After another wild week of the 2014 college football regular season, fans of the sport have already turned their attention to the Week 5 rankings and where the schools they support stand.
It was not a good week to be a ranked program. Florida State and several other teams came close to losing, and other schools like LSU, Missouri, Clemson and Kansas State were defeated and will slide down the ratings.
There will be plenty of turnover in this week’s college football rankings.
Breaking Down the College Football Landscape
It was a tough week to be one of the top teams in the nation. For those ranked teams who managed not to lose, there were several close calls that had top programs sweating a possible loss on Saturday.
Many college football fans believed powerhouses like LSU, Missouri, Clemson and Kansas State would make a serious splash in the new playoff system, but each was handed a loss this week.
Kansas State and Clemson lost to college football juggernauts Auburn and a Jameis Winston-less Florida State respectively, but those defeats will not hurt as much as those suffered by SEC programs LSU and Missouri.
LSU was handed a defeat by the unranked and undefeated Mississippi State in a 34-29 thriller, and Missouri lost to a less-talented Indiana program in an even closer game, 31-27. If you are a fan of either team, it was a long Saturday filled with frustration and sadness.
Mississippi State head coach Dan Mullen told The Associated Press, via ESPN.com, about the victory and the toll it took on him, “I probably aged seven to 10 years in the final three minutes of the game. We are trying to build a program and I'll take it. I guess everybody can now write how I have beaten LSU and Alabama once during my career.”
For other fans, close calls were the name of the game. Several ranked teams came close to losing, but none were closer than Florida State. With Winston suspended for his actions off the field over the last week, the Seminoles faced a tough test against Clemson and managed to pull out the 23-17 win in overtime. FSU proved it had the talent to win without Winston, but the team is clearly better with the former Heisman Trophy winner under center.
The official Twitter of SportsCenter talked about how Winston was still making bad choices Saturday:
Florida State wasn’t the only school involved in a game that was closer than many anticipated. With Oregon beating Washington State, 38-31, and Oklahoma holding off West Virginia, 45-33, supporters of each program were forced to bite their nails as the teams were unable to mount a sizable advantage on Saturday.
The talk has been about the teams that struggled this week, but there were several other top programs that dominated and likely earned even more respect from voters as the teams begin posturing for the postseason.
The biggest winners in Week 4 were Alabama, Texas A&M, Georgia and Wisconsin.
Alabama managed to dominate a tough Florida team on Saturday, but it wasn’t a traditional Crimson Tide victory. Instead of running the ball down Florida’s throat, Alabama leaned on quarterback Blake Sims and his 445 yards and four touchdowns.
Another SEC team that thrived was Texas A&M. SMU never stood a chance, but few saw the 58-6 beatdown coming. The Aggies could have scored even more if they hadn’t taken their foot off the throttle. Staying in the SEC, Georgia was another huge winner, knocking off Troy in spectacular fashion, 66-0. You read that right, folks, Georgia scored 66 on offense and managed to hold Troy to 216 total yards and zero points.
If you’re looking for a winner not getting the credit it deserves, look no further than Wisconsin. The Week 1 loss to LSU is tough to swallow after the Tigers lost on Saturday, but the Badgers destroyed Bowling Green, 68-17. Wisconsin is one of the few highlights for the lackluster Big Ten.
Hopefully, the rest of the season will be as wild as the first four weeks. College football fans certainly hope so.
*Stats via ESPN.com.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
The California Golden Bears led the Arizona Wildcats 31-13 heading into the fourth quarter of their Saturday night Pac-12 showdown. By all accounts, the game was over.
You think you've seen it all.
Arizona scored 36 fourth-quarter points and ultimately won the game on an incredible Hail Mary.
Apparently, the Cal marketing department had gotten a little impatient, sending out a promo email to its subscriber base to celebrate the victory before the game was over. Oops.September 21, 2014
Here's a look at the final play with no time remaining:
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
ESPN's College GameDay is making its first trip of the season to SEC country, where it will watch South Carolina host Missouri in Week 5.
Even after the Gamecocks' Week 1 loss against Texas A&M and the Tigers' Week 4 loss against Indiana, Chris Fowler, Lee Corso, Kirk Herbstreit and the rest of the crew will be in Columbia, South Carolina, to watch a rematch of one of last year's craziest games.
The show's official Twitter account confirmed the news Sunday:
Last season—when this game was played in the other Columbia—Missouri took a 17-0 lead into the fourth quarter. It shut down Gamecocks' quarterback Dylan Thompson, who was playing for an injured Connor Shaw, and looked to be on track to remain undefeated.
But then, in a shocking twist of fate, Shaw entered the game on a sprained knee and led South Carolina to 17 fourth-quarter points. Tied at 17, the game went to overtime, and tied at 24, it went to double overtime. But after a South Carolina field goal in that second frame, Missouri kicker Andrew Baggett missed a 24-yard field goal off the left upright, sealing the Gamecocks' victory, 27-24.
Both of last year's starting quarterbacks—Thompson and Missouri's Maty Mauk—were playing in place of an injured senior starter. Both were regarded among the best backup QBs in college football last season, and both are regarded among the top half of SEC QBs in 2014.
Mauk completed only 10-of-25 passes in last year's game, but those 10 completions went for 249 yards, one touchdown and one interception. "I think he did some really, really good things and a lot of little things he needs to do to get better," Missouri head coach Gary Pinkel said after the game, according to quotes released by the school. "Overall he battled and we will improve and I think he will be a really good player."
Since both of these teams have suffered an embarrassing defeat on their home field this season, one might think this an odd choice for a GameDay location.
However, that might actually raise the stakes.
Whichever team wins this game will advance to 4-1 and control its own fate in the SEC East. Whichever team loses will fall to 3-2 and be pinned against a wall.
Considering these teams combined to go 23-4 in 2013, watching either fall to 3-2 on the season would be a minor shock.
Other big games next week include UCLA at Arizona State—which could not be a GameDay site because it's being played on Thursday—Tennessee at Georgia and Stanford at Washington. But the crew has already seen Stanford play once this season, having traveled to Palo Alto, Calif., when the Cardinal lost to USC in Week 2.
Given the options, this feels like the correct choice.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
Almost every top team faced a tough challenge in Week 4 of the college football season, causing plenty of voters to reconsider their rankings heading into Week 5.
While LSU was the only Top 10 team to lose, there were upset scares involving Florida State, Oregon, Alabama, Oklahoma and Auburn.
When adding this to a few other interesting results throughout the weekend, it creates more confusion surrounding the possibilities for the College Football Playoff. Until then, we can take a look at the latest Amway Coaches Poll from USA Today, along with Bleacher Report's Top 25.
Coming into Saturday, all eyes were on the battle between Florida State and Clemson. Starting quarterback and reigning Heisman Trophy winner Jameis Winston was suspended for the game due to inappropriate conduct, leaving the No. 1 team in the country in the hands of backup Sean Maguire.
After a rough start, Florida State was able to make big plays when needed to force overtime. Clemson was then stopped on fourth down in overtime, allowing the Seminoles to seal the win on a Karlos Williams touchdown.
Head coach Jimbo Fisher discussed the work that went into preparing Maguire for his first career start, via Dan Wolken of USA Today:
It was a lot of work we had to do late, late Friday night and early Saturday all day. A lot of things that had to get done, but life gives you turnips all the time. You have to adjust and move on.
I couldn't be prouder of Sean Maguire tonight, what he did for our team and the resolve he had.
Winston will return next week as Florida State looks to remain undefeated and a top contender for the national championship. However, the Seminoles survived one of the toughest matchups on the schedule and should now have even more confidence going forward.
Meanwhile, Oregon had just as much trouble in a road game at Washington State, barely coming through with a 38-31 win.
Bleacher Report's Barrett Sallee explains the Ducks' shortcomings:
Injuries along the offensive line caused quarterback Marcus Mariota to be under pressure all game long, but he still responded with 329 passing yards and five touchdowns to go with 58 rushing yards in the win.
With UCLA, Stanford and others still looming on the schedule, though, Oregon better figure out how to solve these problems if it wants to stay in the playoff picture.
Oklahoma and Alabama had similar stories from their games as both needed strong individual efforts to pull away late.
The Sooners were tied with West Virginia on the road at halftime until running back Samaje Perine came alive, finishing with 242 rushing yards and four touchdowns. The Crimson Tide were also tied in the second half against Florida, although for them it was Amari Cooper who came through with 10 catches for 201 receiving yards and three touchdowns.
This exciting slate on Saturday almost caused us to overlook a great Thursday night game between Auburn and Kansas State, which the Tigers pulled out thanks to some late mistakes by the home team.
Bleacher Report's Michael Felder was impressed by the win:
The only Top 10 school to lose was LSU, which went down 34-10 at home against Mississippi State before almost completing a comeback. Still, a failed Hail Mary attempt clinched the team's fate in a 34-29 loss. ESPN Stats & Info notes the rarity with this result:
On the other hand, Tim Brando of Fox Sports gives credit to the Bulldogs in what should be an exciting SEC season:
It seems likely that whoever wins the SEC West will get an automatic ticket to the College Football Playoff. Then again, a lot can happen over the next few months as upsets threaten to shake up the rankings.
Week 5 features mostly one-sided battles on paper, although this is usually when the biggest surprises occur. With an intriguing Pac-12 matchup between UCLA and Arizona State taking place on Thursday, there is always something to watch in college football.
Follow Rob Goldberg on Twitter for the latest breaking news and analysis.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
The East Carolina Pirates routed the North Carolina Tar Heels 70-41 on Saturday.
Though the game wasn't all that close, there were some potential NFL players in action for both teams.
While one team clearly shined more than the other, we will look at the long-term NFL prospects for a few players from both teams, in addition to their performances on Saturday.
Another week of college football in the books, another step toward the inaugural College Football Playoff.
There were statement games. Nick Saban's Alabama Crimson Tide went ahead and silenced any doubters with a major win over Florida thanks to the play of one electric quarterback. Texas A&M did much of the same to stay in the hunt, not that any critics were out there as the Kevin Sumlin machine continues to roll along.
There were upsets, too. Mississippi State took down LSU at home. Indiana upended Missouri. Clemson even took Florida State to overtime.
The result is a necessary refresher as to which teams are in the driver's seat in regards to the playoff.
Below, let's take an updated look at playoff projections based on recent results and a peek into the future.
No Jameis Winston, no problem.
All right, that may be a lie, but Florida State remains on top after a nail-biting overtime finish against Clemson. College GameDay puts the win into image form:
The Seminoles defense allowed 407 total yards and quarterback Sean Maguire threw two picks, but Florida State proved game in the face of adversity.
The hero? Wideout Rashad Greene, who brought in nine receptions for 135 yards and a score.
While the game speaks to the true value of Winston, it is only a matter of time before he is back under center. It helps that the coming schedule is rather straightforward until a visit from Notre Dame in the middle of October.
All things equal, the Seminoles remain on the fast track to win the ACC, especially considering the winner of Florida State-Clemson has gone on to do so in each of the past three seasons.
The Oregon Ducks are a lock at this point, barring an epic collapse.
Of course, that almost happened Saturday night, but adversity on the road against Washington State is admirable, at least in a way.
Saturday was a ho-hum affair for the explosive offense, with Heisman contender Marcus Mariota throwing for 329 yards and five scores with all of four incompletions in a 38-31 win.
More impressive, of course, was the season-defining win two weeks ago, when the defensive perennial powerhouse that was then-ranked No. 7 Michigan State came to town and suffered a 46-27 loss behind 318 passing yards and three touchdowns from Mariota.
Given UCLA's consistently iffy form to date, the only real landmine on the schedule that sticks out at this point is the usual date with Stanford. But this year the contest is at home, and the Cardinal is very similar to the Spartans in most ways, meaning should the Ducks stay true to this form then even that contest looks like a win.
The defense and offensive line have questions to answer, but Mariota is a man on a mission. Until further notice, he can will his team to the Playoff.
Remember when quarterback was an issue that could have doomed the Crimson Tide, effectively ending the school's reign of dominance?
Blake Sims is the real deal, folks. He beat out Florida State transfer Jake Coker for the starting gig for good reason, and on Saturday against the Florida Gators he wrote his way into the record books with 445 passing yards and four touchdowns.
Previously, only one other player had thrown for more than 400 yards in school history (Scott Hunter, 484 yards against Auburn in 1969).
Of course, Sims is not alone. As ESPN Stats & Information notes, the Crimson Tide's jaw-dropping 645 total yards is the No. 2 overall output under Saban, with the highest performance coming against Duke.
Florida is no Duke. Derrick Henry contributed on the ground with 111 yards and a score on 20 totes. Amari Cooper continued to look like arguably the best wideout in the nation with 10 receptions for 201 yards and three touchdowns.
On the flip side, the Crimson Tide limited the Gators to 200 yards of total offense and allowed just two third-down conversions on 13 attempts.
Alabama is here to stay as long as Sims can continue to utilize the talent around him to great success. Hurdles such as games against Texas A&M, LSU and Auburn will be tough, but there is absolutely nothing to suggest the Crimson Tide will not be in the running come Playoff time.
It is entirely too easy to overlook Baylor, especially as Week 4 was a bye for Art Briles' team.
That in no way eliminates the Bears from consideration.
The Bears once again tout an elite offense behind the hot arm of Heisman contender Bryce Petty. A 45-0 win over SMU was nice. A 70-6 win over Northwestern State was expected. A 63-21 triumph on the road over Buffalo is the most impressive of all to this point.
While the biggest tests are yet to come for Petty and Co., it is abundantly clear that the team continues to fire on all cylinders thanks to continuity at a number of key positions. In just two games, Petty has not skipped a beat en route to 577 yards with six touchdowns and no interceptions.
He is also once again supported by an elite stable of backs, as the numbers show:
Perhaps scariest of all is that the Bears keep rolling in the face of injury.
"Everyone I started out the summer with isn't on the field right now," Petty said, referring to his depleted group of receivers, per The Associated Press (h/t FoxSports.com). "It's kind of weird. But I thought those guys did a great job of just stepping up."
While contests against Oklahoma State and Kansas State loom large near the end of the season, the game that may very well determine the Bears' playoff candidacy outright comes against the Oklahoma Sooners near the beginning of November.
Considering the Sooners had their fair share of struggles Saturday against West Virginia, what Petty and his offense can do to that defense will be quite interesting indeed.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com
Week 4 of the college football season was supposed to be a fairly easy one on the ranked teams that were in action. As it turned out, quite a few were pushed and some were even bitten by the upset bug.
No. 1 Florida State needed overtime to knock off No. 22 Clemson without the suspended Jameis Winston. The No. 2 Oregon Ducks needed its Heisman front-runner to show why most consider him the best player in the nation.
Marcus Mariota almost single-handedly saved the Ducks from an embarrassing loss to the Washington State Cougars in the latest game on the day's schedule.
This trend actually began on Thursday when the No. 5 Auburn Tigers narrowly escaped No. 20 Kansas State Wildcats 20-14. Perhaps we should've sensed there would be tight games on Saturday.
Here's a look at how all of the ranked teams in action fared.
Indiana Shocks Missouri at Home
The Missouri Tigers hadn't lost all season, and they hadn't lost at home to a nonconference opponent since 2012. Both of those things happened on Saturday.
On the strength of a late touchdown drive and a run game that tallied 241 yards, the Indiana Hoosiers handed the Tigers a 31-27 loss. Tevin Coleman ran for 132 of those yards.
With most teams below them holding serve, or having the day off, the Tigers could plummet out of the Top 25.
Mississippi State Holds off LSU
The LSU Tigers started horribly, but it finished strong. Unfortunately, the start was too dank to recover from. Mississippi State ran for 302 yards and quarterback Dak Prescott combined for 373 total yards and three total touchdowns.
LSU trailed 31-10 after three quarters, but behind Brandon Harris, who relieved Anthony Jennings, the Tigers outscored Mississippi State 19-3 in the fourth quarter.
Harris' desperation heave was intercepted, and the Bulldogs had earned a 34-29 victory over LSU in Baton Rouge. The win ended a 14-year losing streak against LSU.
The Close Calls
BYU Rallies to Hold off Virginia
In Week 3, the Virginia Cavaliers upset the Louisville Cardinals and knocked them from the Top 25. The BYU Cougars were intent upon avoiding the same fate against the Cavs.
The Cougars were outplayed in almost every aspect, but somehow they came away with the 41-33 win. Virginia outgained the Cougars 519-332, and BYU committed 12 penalties for 133 yards. The Cavs also had the ball for over 40 minutes to just over 19 for BYU.
The Cougars' saving grace was its bend-but-don't-break defense. It forced Virginia to settle for four Ian Frye field goals. None of them was longer 46 yards.
A win is a win, but BYU wasn't exactly impressive.
Winston-less Seminoles Survive Clemson
Without their reigning Heisman Trophy winner, Florida State struggled to score against the stout Clemson defense. The Seminoles converted just four of 15 third-down attempts, and Sean Maguire threw two interceptions as Winston's replacement.
The game went into overtime, where Karlos Williams clinched the win for the Noles with a 12-yard touchdown run.
While Florida State will gladly take the win, this close call caps off a week the program would like to put behind them as soon as possible.
Mariota to the Rescue
Connor Halliday and the Washington State Cougars came to play on Saturday. Halliday threw for 436 yards and four touchdowns, but it wasn't enough as Mariota played like a front-runner for the Heisman in leading his team to victory.
Despite being sacked seven times, Mariota completed 21 of 25 passes for 329 yards and five touchdowns. Dealing with a makeshift offensive line because of various injuries, Mariota was under pressure all game.
The defense also struggled to get a handle on Halliday and Co.
Oregon as a team was not at its best, but Mariota couldn't have played better under the circumstances.
Spartans Smite the Eagles
Perhaps the Michigan State Spartans needed to let out their frustrations after losing 46-27 to Oregon in Week 3.
The Eastern Michigan Eagles were simply in the wrong place at the wrong time. The score of the game was 49-0 at halftime, and the 73-14 final tally capped off one of the most lopsided games you'll ever see, hear or read about.
The Badgers Like to Run
It's safe to say, if a team racks up a Big-Ten record 644 rushing yards, there's a pretty good chance it'll win. The Wisconsin Badgers demolished Bowling Green 68-17.
It truly looked as if Wisconsin was running the football against a high-level high school squad.
It averaged a whopping 10.7 yards per carry and had three players top 100 yards on the day. Chief among them was Melvin Gordon. He ran for 253 yards and a ridiculous five touchdowns.
Georgia Silences Men of Troy
Another team still smarting from a tough loss was the Georgia Bulldogs. On Saturday, Georgia allowed just 216 total yards, but most importantly, it gave up zero points against Troy.
This was supposed to be a blowout, and it was.
Texas A&M Rolls over SMU
The Texas A&M Aggies offense is downright scary. By now, we all have all heard of Kenny "Trill" Hill, but the Aggies' attack is even deeper than its talented young quarterback.
In Saturday's 58-6 demolition of SMU, the Aggies had 663 yards of total offense, and it only had the ball for 23:53. It's clear that it doesn't take long for this explosive bunch to do major damage.
Arkansas is next as the team heads into the heart of its SEC schedule.
Read more College Football news on BleacherReport.com