NCAA Football News

Grading Every New Power 5 Conference Coach's First Recruiting Class

Whether it's a crucial game week or an uneventful offseason stretch in the winter, college football coaches must always bring effort to a frenzied recruiting trail. Among America's most elite high school prospects, the vast majority begin receiving significant collegiate interest as underclassmen.

National signing day, which took place last Friday, is the culmination of years on the grind for coaches who've pursued players through multiple seasons. The process becomes even more challenging for a university when administration elects to make a coaching change or the head coach departs for an opportunity elsewhere.

When the 2016 season kicks off, there will be 13 head coaches in Power Five conference competition who weren't in that position a year ago. While wins and losses will ultimately develop the narrative of their respective inaugural endeavors, the first opportunity to impress arrived on signing day. 

Some of these new regimes had just weeks to salvage past commitments and piece together fresh pledges during a frantic final stretch. Here's a look at how we graded each initial class for these 13 head coaches, considering overall talent value and the program dynamics they inherited.

Begin Slideshow

Nick Saban Has Built Alabama as the Clear 'Linebacker U' of College Football

TUSCALOOSA, Ala. — It began with an impromptu press conference hastily called in 2009. 

Linebacker Rolando McClain didn’t suspect anything major when he received a phone call the Monday following the SEC Championship Game telling him to be at the football building the next morning; he was scheduled for a meeting with head coach Nick Saban followed by an interview session with media.

However, his suspicions were slightly aroused when being told to dress up, which was different because when players are on camera they almost always wear something Crimson Tide–related.

“I was thinking, ‘Why do I need to wear slacks and a collared shirt?’” McClain said. “We don’t do media like that.”

He was still completely surprised when Dick Butkus walked into Saban’s office carrying his namesake trophy that annually goes to the nation’s best linebacker.

“I had no idea,” McClain said. “I’m really at a loss for words. I didn’t expect it.”

“He was really surprised,” Saban said. “It was a lot of fun.” 

Ever since then Crimson Tide reporters have been on high alert in early December as the program has repeatedly had players in the running for the award. The only years Alabama hasn’t had a finalist were 2010 and 2014.

When C.J. Mosley won in 2013, Butkus surprised him at the team banquet, and a strong argument could be made that Reggie Ragland was deserving this past season.

“Anytime you’re a competitor, I always want to win everything,” said Ragland, who used his close second-place finish to Notre Dame’s Jaylon Smith as motivation for the playoffs. “A good guy won it. I can’t be mad. I’ll take it with a grain of salt and keep moving forward.”

Nevertheless, Alabama has become the standard when it comes to linebackers, which was only reinforced last week when it landed two 5-star recruits at the position, Ben Davis and Lyndell Wilson.

According to the 247Sports composite rankings, they were the fifth and sixth 5-star linebackers to sign with Alabama under Saban, joining Nico Johnson (2009), Trey DePriest (2011), Reuben Foster (2013) and Rashaan Evans (2014).

Meanwhile, in five of the last seven seasons Alabama has had a consensus/unanimous All-American at linebacker, which easily tops the nation. During that time period only Georgia, Notre Dame and Michigan State have had two, and for the Spartans it was Greg Jones named twice.

On the flip side of that, since the 2010 NFL draft there have been 19 linebackers selected in the first round, led by Alabama with three (McClain, Mosley and Dont’a Hightower, while Courtney Upshaw just missed). Ragland appears poised to be the fourth.

Consequently, it’s time Alabama claim the "Linebacker U" designation.

For years Penn State was known for that under head coach Joe Paterno, and rightfully so. Beginning with Dennis Onkotz, a two-time All-American in 1968-69, the Nittany Lions had the reputation for regularly having outstanding players at the position. 

Others included Jack Ham, John Skorupan, Greg Buttle, Shane Conlan, LaVar Arrington, Brandon Short and Paul Posluszny, who were all consensus All-Americans.

Nevertheless, Penn State’s only had the third-most consensus All-Americans at linebacker since 1965, when the NCAA got rid of its rules requiring the use of the one-platoon system which forced players to play on offense and defense.

The most recent player to join that club was Dan Connor in 2007, when he finished his career as Penn State’s all-time leading tackler with 419.

Yes, that’s the same year Saban landed in Tuscaloosa, and when McClain began his collegiate career. One of the holdovers from Mike Shula’s recruiting efforts, the in-state product started eight of 13 games as a freshman, finishing with 75 tackles, two interceptions and a sack.

That year, safety Rashad Johnson led the team with 94 tackles, while tied for second with 80 were defensive lineman Wallace Gilberry and linebacker Darren Mustin, a transfer from Middle Tennessee State. (Note: Johnson, a former walk-on at running back, now plays for the Arizona Cardinals. Gilberry plays with the Cincinnati Bengals). It's the last time Alabama failed to notch at least 10 wins.

Meanwhile, Alabama’s history includes Derrick Thomas, Cornelius Bennett, Lee Roy Jordan and Woodrow Lowe, who will stand up against any four linebackers in history.

All four are in the College Football Hall of Fame, which is one more linebacker than Penn State has had enshrined. 

As for Butkus—who played before 1965 and was listed as a unanimous All-American at center in 1963 and a consensus selection in 1964, but was voted into the College Football Hall of Fame as a linebacker—no one would be surprised if he keeps making return trips to Tuscaloosa.

Foster will attract a lot of offseason hype along with sack artists Tim Williams and Ryan Anderson, but down the road there’s Davis, Evans, Wilson, Christian Miller, Shaun Dion Hamilton …


Quotes were obtained firsthand unless otherwise noted.

Christopher Walsh is a lead SEC college football writer. Follow Christopher on Twitter @WritingWalsh

Read more College Football news on