Investigation continues around oil-train derailment, fire in Custer, Whatcom County

By Elise Takahama , Ron Judd and Lynda V. Mapes

The Seattle Times

Jenny Reich was preparing to open her glass shop in Custer, Whatcom County, on Tuesday afternoon when there was a loud noise and suddenly “everything was shaking.”

Reich, a longtime Custer resident, said she is so accustomed to the rumble that’s part of living close to a rail line that she doesn’t usually notice the trains anymore.

But this time, a plume of black smoke obscured the view from her window. Emergency personnel arrived at the scene. And shortly after, Reich was advised to evacuate her business, Whimsy Art Glass. She grabbed her wallet, keys and dog and hit the road.

Down the street from her art studio, a 108-car BNSF Railway train carrying Bakken crude oil had derailed and some of the cars caught fire — closing roads, forcing temporary evacuations and highlighting the risks Washington faces in the transportation of the highly volatile crude oil, whose shipments have sparked controversy in the past.

Two BNSF Railway employees were on board the train at the time, but no injuries were reported, Whatcom County Sheriff Bill Elfo said during a Tuesday afternoon news conference.

Seven of the tank cars derailed and two ignited around 11:40 a.m. in the 7500 block of Portal Way, according to a Tuesday afternoon statement from BNSF. The train was headed toward the Phillips 66 refinery in Ferndale.

By 3 p.m., firefighters had brought the blaze under control, though the cause of the derailment remains under investigation, the Sheriff’s Office said.

An evacuation order, which was initially put in place for everyone within a half-mile of the wreck, was lifted for Custer residents around 4:45 p.m., according to the Sheriff’s Office.

“BNSF will coordinate with authorities as the investigation proceeds,” a statement from the railway said. “Our thoughts are with those who have been affected by this incident. We will provide additional details as they become available.”

During the conference, Elfo also acknowledged recent federal charges against two people for allegedly placing “shunts” on BNSF tracks and said FBI investigators were on scene Tuesday.

“At this point, it would be speculative to connect other events with this incident,” an FBI spokesperson wrote. “FBI Seattle encourages anyone with knowledge of the train derailment to contact tips.fbi.gov.”

Interstate 5 temporarily closed between Grandview Road and Birch Bay Lynden Road, but reopened at 2 p.m. in both directions, according to the Washington State Department of Transportation. Local roads remained closed as of 5 p.m.

The National Transportation Safety Board will investigate the derailment, said spokesperson Eric Weiss. “We’re interested in the performance of the tank cars. We’ve been following crude-oil training and safety for years so we want to see how they performed.”

Weiss said officials are waiting for the cars to “cool down” before investigators determine next steps.

The Tuesday incident resurfaced an ongoing debate about the Pacific Northwest’s key role in crude-oil transport.

Oil trains are called “bomb trains” by their critics because the Bakken crude — which is more volatile than many other crudes due to elevated levels of gases such as ethane, propane and butane — they carry is explosive. The trains wind along fragile environments in Washington, including the Columbia River and Puget Sound, and through communities from downtown Seattle to hamlets near the U.S.-Canada border, including Custer. The trains also travel along the I-5 corridor.

The most recent oil-train derailment in the Pacific Northwest was in June 2016 near Mosier, Oregon, when several rail cars derailed in the Columbia River Gorge east of Portland. Emergency responders were able to put out the fire before it spread, and no injuries or deaths were reported.

The train derailed for unknown reasons less than half a mile from the Columbia River, and it was only lucky that the wind wasn’t roaring through the gorge that day to spread the flames.

A 2013 explosion of an oil train in Lac-Megantic in Quebec caught the world’s attention when 47 people were killed and 1.5 million gallons of crude were spilled.

Oil trains have become a daily risk in the Northwest because of the boom in U.S. shale oil production, in which producers extract crude oil from shale rock formations. The process has unleashed a gusher of domestic oil, which has tanked gasoline prices and reduced U.S. dependence on foreign oil, but also poses unique risks for Washington and Oregon.

The two states are the critical corridors for crude oil from North Dakota’s Bakken oil fields to refineries in Washington. Every year, 20 billion gallons of oil moves through Washington by vessel, rail and pipeline.

Washington has one of the lowest spill rates in the nation, according to U.S. Coast Guard data. The state has a zero-spill standard. But spills happen, primarily in the I-5 corridor, mapping by the state Department of Ecology shows.

The most recent report by Ecology on crude-oil movement through Washington shows that from July through September of this year, more than 14 million barrels, or more than 595 million gallons of crude, was transported by rail through Washington from North Dakota, and Alberta, and Saskatchewan in Canada.

Every week on average, during the most recent quarter alone, more than a million barrels of crude — or 45 million gallons of oil — moved by rail through Washington in a total of more than 20,000 cars. That’s an average of more than 1,500 rail cars per week.

There were no spills reported from train transport of oil during the most recent quarterly reporting period.