NCAA Football News

Are College Football Playoff Committee Members Set Up for Failure?

ATLANTA — I watched games Saturday from the sidelines and then from the couch. In doing so, I gained a better understanding of the problem facing the College Football Playoff Selection Committee. 

These 13 fine people are too far away.

They have too many other things to do.

They are not set up for success.

I watched from 20 yards away in the Georgia Dome as the left side of Alabama's offensive line mauled two WVU defenders at the point of attack—just knocked them to the ground—and second-string running back Derrick Henry ran 19 yards for a touchdown. West Virginia had players down all over the field in the first half Saturday. TV does not capture the physical nature of that.

I watched from 20 yards away as WVU's Rushel Shell went 14 yards because Bama backup linebacker Reuben Foster and new starting linebacker Reggie Ragland were influenced by a man in motion in the WVU backfield and froze. The play came back opposite the motion, and the flat-footed linebackers were sealed off. Lined up in a nickel defense to combat the spread, the Tide were missing veteran linebacker Trey DePriest (suspended).

Both Henry's run and Shell's were double-digit gains, so they showed up on the stat sheets and the broadcasts. But the view from the ground revealed much more about the differences between the two teams. Alabama was more physical and deeper, which helped explain how the Tide could roll up 538 yards using a scat-back quarterback, a new starter, whose passes were no more than 10 yards down field (run-after-catch effect). The final score was 33-23, but the talent on the two sides, and who was playing and who wasn't, suggested the difference between the teams was much wider.

The committee's view—for most games—is from 20,000 feet, or the 10 feet to their television, or the 10 inches from their noses to their iPad screen, or from the skybox to the field.

"We are not sending committee members to games; they will be watching games on television and watching video replays," said Gina Lehe, Senior Director of Communications and Brand Management for the playoff committee.  "We do not have any information about what they did Saturday."

The fact that just three members of the committee are former coaches doesn't bother me like it bothers Barry Switzer or Pat Dye. What bothers me is these people are not on the ground at these games.

They are too far away, too detached, too part-time. They have other jobs. We're talking about a multi-million dollar enterprise, and we have 13 people involved who are all very smart but are not grinding full-time on this endeavor of picking the four best teams in college football. If you are going to pick four teams, you have to have intimate knowledge, especially when it comes to the big decision, which is not "Who's No. 1?" but "Who's No. 4?"

Think back to 2011. Alabama and Oklahoma State were one-loss teams, and one had to be picked to play LSU for the title. The Crimson Tide edged out the Cowboys in the BCS rankings, and everyone outside the SEC footprint howled. I talked to scouts who had seen both teams up close, and they said there was a considerable difference in talent between the teams and Alabama would win by three scores over the Cowboys. Alabama would be the better match for LSU.

The Crimson Tide ended up winning the national title, 21-0, over LSU.

Think back to Oregon in 2012 and 2013. Stanford controlled the offensive line in back-to-back wins over the Ducks, who were being labeled invincible because of the offense. The TV showed the Ducks to be a great team. It's something you have to see up close.

Here is something else, the committee, or most of them, are missing by watching so much replay. They miss the visceral feel of the action. By the time they watch some games, they know what's coming. The Wow is gone. They have a tape. They've heard about it.

While chairman Jeff Long was watching his Arkansas team wilt in the third quarter at Auburn, he was missing Georgia's Todd Gurley gash Clemson.

While Clemson athletic director Dan Radakovich was watching his Tigers cave against Georgia, he was missing Florida State's uneven performance against Oklahoma State.

While Barry Alvarez, the Wisconsin athletic director, was busy with the Badgers loss to LSU, FSU was on its way to a win, but without the same ferociousness as 2013.

While Oliver Luck, the West Virginia AD, was watching WVU try and hold off Alabama's vast talent, Ohio State was finally putting away Navy.

There are too many games to watch at once, at least until later in the season when the contenders are thinned out. How do you impress somebody when the shock value has been extracted by "I knew that was coming"?

You have to hand it to Long, though. This is a lot of work for an AD who oversees a $100 million budget. He watches games on TV in his hotel room prior to departure for Hogs' away games, then he is on to mobile devices. Conferences offices send him every game in the form of coach's video, both sideline and end zone views of all plays.

Long, who was a graduate assistant football coach at Michigan under offensive line coach Les Miles, has 20 prime TV games made available to him per week without commercials or time in between plays, according to a member of his staff. Long and other committee members have access to Sports Source Analytics, which is the granular version of the game on the TV.

Here's the problem with not being closer to the action. Anybody see a great team out there the first week? Texas A&M—on one side of the ball. Auburn—on one side of the ball. Florida State—for a quarter.

If there is not a great team, or two great teams, there are going to be some one-loss teams. Maybe not this year, but as schools beef up strength of schedule to build their resume for the CFP and bow to TV, we are going to have one-loss teams galore.

It's why this committee should have been scouts, former NFL GMs, retired coaches in their 50s and 60s who could still travel and work 50-60 hours a week. It would have been a little harder to argue with them over the biggest looming debate in college athletics—who is No. 4, who is No. 5? There is plenty of money to pay for people's time.

It's a little late for this, but I would have called Bill Polian, the former NFL general manager, and asked for some names. Of course, the scouts and former GMs are not part of the college club. Their names were not pushed forward by the National Football Foundation or the Autonomous 5 Commissioners. I asked selection committee executive director Bill Hancock last year if he would consider the idea and he said no.

I am not going where Dye went, about stacking the committee with coaches and players who have "put their hand in the dirt." Switzer, the former Oklahoma coach, mimicked Dye recently about committee member Condi Rice not being qualified. Switzer probably made the same comments about reporters as he did about Rice. You haven't been there, you know nothin'.

Dr. Rice's analytical skills would embarrass me. Her judgment is off the charts; she won't be swayed by emotion. I would be fine having somebody with her credentials on the committee if she went to enough games, saw more teams in person, stood next to a 6'9" offensive lineman who can't move his feet to block and a 6'4" lineman who can. If she saw it up close, I'm sure Condi could tell me who the better player is.

It's not too late to tell the people on this committee to get out to some Thursday night and Friday night games.

The caretakers of college football have left themselves open to criticism because they chose administrators and people connected to the money game to make sure there is a sharing of the wealth, instead of choosing pure football people, or people not in the "club", who might be more likely to put two SEC teams or two Pac-12 teams in the Final Four.

I'm not questioning the integrity of somebody like Tom Jernstedt. This is questioning the judgment of the College Football Playoff Management Committee and the Autonomous Power 5 commissioners.

The big takeaway here is that this committee chosen by politics is bound to get slammed for prejudice. Then the squawking about who gets left out eventually leads to talk of an eight-team playoff. How about that? We will be a year into a 12-year deal, and already there will be backroom plans being made to get more money from the fans via television with an eight-team playoff under the guise "we have to include more worthy teams."

More teams, more injury risk, more missed class time. Why not squash some of the debate with more time on the sidelines or in the huddle for the 13.


Ray Glier has covered college football and various other sports for 20 years.  His work has appeared in USA Today, The New York Times, CNN, The Washington Post and Al Jazeera America. He is the author of How the SEC Became Goliath (Howard/Simon & Schuster, 2013)

Read more College Football news on

Florida State Football: Report Card Grades for Every New Starter

Florida State officially kicked off its title defense this past Saturday by holding off Oklahoma State in a 37-31 victory, and several new starting Seminoles played integral roles in the opening-weekend win.

With several former players off to the NFL, FSU had multiple starting positions to fill this offseason, and their replacements had mixed results against the Cowboys at AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas.

Click the slideshow to see what each of FSU's new starters did in game No. 1 and a grade of their performances.

Begin Slideshow

Grading Bobby Petrino's Return to Big-Time College Football

With apologies to the one-year stint with Western Kentucky in 2013, Monday night marked the return of Bobby Petrino to big-time college football.

Now in the first year of his second stint as the head coach of the Louisville Cardinals, the former Arkansas head coach pounded the Miami Hurricanes 31-13.

It was about what you'd expect from a Petrino-coached team.

The Cardinals established the running game, got efficient play in the passing game and leaned on the Hurricanes late to pull away in the second half of what was not only Petrino's first game back, but the first game for Louisville as a member of the ACC.

How did his encore grade out?


Offense: B

It wasn't the kind of performance that Petrino's teams are accustomed to, with the quarterback slinging the ball all over the field and the scoreboard lighting up with crooked numbers.

It was efficient. It was smart. It was effective.

Quarterback Will Gardner completed 20 of 28 passes for 206 yards, two touchdowns and zero interceptions, which is certainly good enough. However, two fumbles—including one in the red zone—helped keep the game unnecessarily close early.

“Other than the turnovers, I mean a couple fumbles. Other than that I am but there is always room to improve and get better and just come out next week, work hard and get ready for the next event,” Gardner said.

While ball security was an issue, Petrino suggested some of Garnder's issues can be fixed with pass protection.

"A lot of the hits were caused of making the wrong call, we didn’t block the right guy," Petrino told reporters. "He still has to get the ball against his body. You talk about poise and competitive spirit, the way he came out and played after those mistakes, I’m very proud of him."

On the ground, the Cardinals were fine.

Without an injured Michael Dyer, Dominique Brown took over against a Miami defense that has some run-stuffers in the front seven, including Denzel Perryman. Brown had 33 carries for 143 yards and a touchdown in the win, and he took a ton of pressure off Gardner.

“It’s a great feeling," Brown said following the game. "You know when you’ve got the offensive line behind you—especially with the head coach calling the plays to me, just telling me to stay out there and 'we’re gonna keep feeding you'—it's a great feeling.”

The protection issues and Gardner's ball security are concerning and what prevented this grade from being an "A."


Defense: A

I'll be honest, I was shocked at Louisville's defense against Miami on Monday night.

After four years of confusion, ineptitude and inconsistency in Athens, Petrino paid Todd Grantham $1 million per year to coordinate the Cardinals defense. It looked comfortable, properly taught and fundamentally sound against the 'Canes.

Grantham's defense forced three turnovers, held Miami to 1-of-13 on third-down conversions and forced running back Duke Johnson to cut behind the line of scrimmage early and often, limiting his effectiveness.

This put too much pressure on true freshman quarterback Brad Kaaya.

"I think we did a good job of being gap-sound and our guys using their hands to get off blocks," Petrino said. "I like the way our linebackers played coming downhill and our secondary was involved in being where they needed to be."

Was that hefty contract to Grantham worth it?

So far, so good.


Special Teams: A

The Cardinals were good in essentially every aspect of special teams.

Corvin Lamb had a 97-yard kickoff return for a touchdown, showing off blazing speed and quickly shifting momentum back to the home team after Miami had taken a 10-7 lead. Lamb showed off tremendous speed and elusiveness on the return, which makes him a dangerous weapon for the Cards moving forward.

"He’s a guy whose speed shows up every day in practice," Petrino said. "I think we’ve just got to find a way to get him the ball and get him involved in our offense as well as special teams."

John Wallace hit all four of his extra points and his only field-goal attempt (28 yards), while Ryan Johnson averaged 44 yards per punt.

Can't get much better than that from a special teams perspective.


Overall: A-

There are some issues to work out, particularly with Gardner's ball security and the protection up front. But make no mistake, Louisville made a statement on Monday night that it is a contender in the ACC Atlantic.

Is it better than Florida State or Clemson?

That remains to be seen, but each of those two front-runners showed its fair share of weaknesses as well—plus Louisville gets the 'Noles at home on a Thursday night on Oct. 30.

The Cardinals are in the discussion, and that's about as good as it could possibly get after Week 1.


Barrett Sallee is the lead SEC college football writer and video analyst for Bleacher Report, and co-host of the CFB Hangover on Bleacher Report Radio (Sundays 9-11 a.m. ET) on Sirius 93 XM 208. Quotes were obtained firsthand unless otherwise noted. All stats are courtesy of, and all recruiting information is courtesy of 247Sports.


Read more College Football news on

NCAA Football Playoff 2014: Latest Predictions After Week 1 Standings

From the looks of college football's opening week, the NCAA picked the perfect season to institute the College Football Playoff.

There's no powerhouse that looks poised to run away with the top ranking. If the newly instituted postseason began today, any of the participating squads would enter the melee with a solid chance of coming out on top.

While South Carolina saw its CFB chances vanish, the top-seeded teams all exited Week 1 with a victory. That's enough to keep them in the top four for now, but it might not stay that way for long in a deep pool of contenders.

Note, these rankings reflect my predictions for the next AP poll. I have the No. 2 and 3 squads swapping places for now, but don't be surprised if bigger changes ensue later in the season.


Projected College Football Playoff Matchups:

No. 1 Florida State vs. No. 4 Oklahoma

Florida State came dangerously close to ruining its title defense just as it began. Oklahoma State pushed the Seminoles to the brink in a 37-31 loss.

Jameis Winston compiled 370 passing yards, but he also coughed up two interceptions that kept the Cowboys hopeful. He told Yahoo Sports' Pat Forde that the team needs to play better after surviving a close call.

"We got to get better," Winston said. "I told the guys, 'Hey, that’s an eye opener.' [The Cowboys] played their tails off. So we got to go higher."

The defending Heisman Trophy winner hardly deserves all of the blame. The team averaged 3.4 yards per carry while allowing three opposing scores through the ground.

Since they're the defending champions, expect the Seminoles to receive the benefit of the doubt for now. They should return to normalcy with a convincing victory over The Citadel on Saturday night.

Oklahoma took a positive in proving it belongs among the nation's top squads. Bob Stoops' squad outgained Louisiana Tech by 191 yards during a 48-16 Week 1 victory.

The Sooners imposed their will on the ground, gaining 183 rushing yards and five touchdowns with Samaje Perine leading the brigade. While they would have been considered a sizable underdog against Florida State a week ago, the Sooners may feel a bit more optimistic about their chances now. 


No. 2 Oregon vs. No. 3 Alabama

The Crimson Tide better watch themselves if they don't want to fall any further. 

Yes, they best West Virginia last weekend, but a 33-23 victory won't garner them championship praise. Clint Trickett kept the Mountaineers alive with 365 passing yards, exposing a once feared secondary.

Quarterbacks Blake Sims and Jacob Coker were expected to enter the opener in a timeshare, but the fifth-year senior instead played every snap. Sims held his own, going 24-of-33 with 250 yards passing and 42 rushing, but he also surrendered an interception during the fourth quarter. 

Sports Illustrated's Zac Ellis wonders how this game will affect Alabama's quarterback controversy going forward.

Now, fans must wait and see whether the Blake Sims show has truly taken over in Tuscaloosa. Coker remains a highly touted option, but perhaps Saban and offensive coordinator Lane Kiffin will embrace one simple mantra: If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. The real question is whether Sims can perform similarly against Alabama’s SEC schedule.

If last weekend's game is any indication, Alabama will eventually need a signal-caller who can do more than tread water. Alongside a mortal-looking defense in a loaded SEC, Nick Saban should eventually turn to the Florida State transfer if he wants to keep this playoff spot.

No such dilemma exists in Oregon, where Heisman hopeful Marcus Mariota scored four touchdowns in Oregon's 62-13 opening win over South Dakota. In the process, he broke Joey Harrington's school record for touchdowns, as noted by assistant athletic director Andy McNamara.

A year removed from finishing second in total offensive yards and third in points scored, the Ducks are showing no signs of slowing down this season. They'll face arguably their toughest challenge of the year this Saturday in No. 8 Michigan State, an early showdown with major CFB implications.

While a loss clouds the playoff picture, a win over the Spartans puts Oregon in No. 1 consideration.

Read more College Football news on

NCAA Football Rankings 2014: Week 2 Standings for College's Top 25 Teams

A wild Week 1 in college football is likely to produce some huge shakeups when the updated rankings are released. But prior to the polls being released, it's time to take a look back at where each team started the season.

With the updated rankings set to be announced after the first games were played, several teams helped their case. Meanwhile, other programs took a step back during their season openers.

After impressing the voters in Week 1, teams like Georgia and Baylor will likely see a jump in the standings. As for South Carolina and Clemson, a drop in the rankings is likely after disappointing losses.

Before the updated polls are released, here's a look at the most recent Bleacher Report rankings and a breakdown of how teams shifted in the standings.


Breakdown of Rankings

A record-breaking performance and resounding victory in Week 1 was enough to thrust Texas A&M up the rankings.

The Aggies' 52-28 win over South Carolina proved that the team is ready to move forward without Johnny Manziel. While the defense still allowed 28 points to the Gamecocks, it was the phenomenal offense that made waves around the college football landscape.

In particular, Kenny Hill more than emerged from the shadow of Manziel in his first college start. Numbers Never Lie takes a look at the signal-caller's first game compared to the previous field general:

Not only is the Texas A&M program now back in the spotlight, but Hill appears to have Heisman hopes. Following a season in which Jameis Winston unexpectedly won the award, Hill has a good shot if he continues putting up huge numbers.

Speaking of Winston, the sophomore struggled slightly in his opener. But with the win over Oklahoma State, Florida State remains atop the Bleacher Report rankings and will likely stay on top of both the AP and Amway polls when they are released.

But with a favorable schedule that includes just one potential test against Clemson before facing Notre Dame on Oct. 18, the Seminoles will likely remain at No. 1 moving forward. While Winston wasn't flawless, he showed flashes of brilliance with a huge run, as SportsCenter notes:

As for those who took a dive in the standings, Wisconsin was likely the one team that is the most befuddling. Not because of the result against LSU but how the program got there.

Melvin Gordon is the clear star for the Badgers, but he was limited to just four carries in the second half against the Tigers. With only 16 touches, he still produced 140 yards and a touchdown on the big stage.

Head coach Gary Andersen spoke about the disappearance of Gordon in the second half, per Zach Heilprin of ESPN Wisconsin:

Yes, that is the head coach saying he didn't know why his biggest playmaker only toted the ball twice in the fourth quarter. Meanwhile, LSU scored 15 unanswered points in the final frame to win—something that Wisconsin fans won't soon forget.

Along with Wisconsin, both South Carolina and Clemson are sure to slide down in the polls. But as the season goes on, the focus will likely be on the top teams with hopes of making the College Football Playoff.

Whether some of the early surprises emerge into the top four will be something to watch moving forward. Given the way the first week shaped up, the 2014 season is guaranteed to be an unpredictable one with plenty of surprises in store.


Follow @RCorySmith on Twitter.

Read more College Football news on

Ohio State Football: The Key to Saving J.T. Barrett's Season

What's the difference between an "OK" performance and a "very good" one?

Sometimes, it's just one play.

That's the message Urban Meyer delivered on Monday when discussing J.T. Barrett's college debut. Ohio State may have beaten Navy by a 34-17 margin in the Buckeyes' season opener on Saturday, but the one play that seemed to stand out to most was Barrett's second-quarter red-zone interception—the type of mental mistake that many expected to see from a redshirt freshman in the first start of his college career.

The play clearly clouded Meyer's opinion of Barrett's performance, which he admitted was significantly altered by the first-year starter's lone turnover.

"J.T. did OK," Meyer said on Monday. "He handled himself very well for his first start. You take away the interception, and I think he did very well."

And while that's a more than fair assessment—after all, it was Barrett's decision that resulted in the interception—it also doesn't take into account the entirety of the play. Because before Barrett made his opinion-altering throw, he faced—and avoided—significant pressure from the Midshipmen defense before letting go of a pass that landed in the hands of Navy safety Parrish Gaines.

But while the blame for the interception remains with Barrett, that's not to say that Meyer didn't also walk away from the Buckeyes' season opener disappointed with the play of his offensive line. In fact, the third-year Ohio State head coach admitted that the unit's play was his top concern leaving Saturday's game.

And for good reason. Replacing four multiyear starters from a season ago, the Buckeyes' front five looked shaky at best—particularly early—and ultimately affected Ohio State's play-calling for the better part of the first three quarters of the game.

"We had some pressure. We wanted to throw the ball earlier, and it wasn't because of J.T. or the wideouts because I thought our guys had made plays," Meyer said when asked about his offensive line on Monday. "I have a lot of confidence in J.T., but we couldn't have minus-yardage plays, and it didn't start off very well."

While the Buckeyes offensive line eventually found its footing and helped pave the way for a 28-point second half, Ohio State can hardly afford a similar slow start this Saturday when Virginia Tech comes to town. The Hokies possess an experienced and aggressive front seven, which, paired with college football expert Phil Steele's top-ranked preseason secondary, could make for as talented of a defense as the Buckeyes will face this season.

That's something that Meyer's well aware of, which is perhaps why he remains so concerned with the spotty play that he saw from his offensive line on Saturday. He also knows that his team won't be able to get away with a similar effort on Saturday, as Virginia Tech will make Ohio State pay, should it leave Barrett vulnerable to the Hokies defense.

“The second half we played pretty good. But pretty good is not what we expect," Meyer said. "You play pretty good this week, you won't win that game. So we have to get much better fast in the offensive line.”

For their part, the players who make up the Buckeyes offensive line believe they're on their way toward accomplishing just that. Ohio State's lone returning starter on the line, left tackle Taylor Decker, said that Saturday's showing was simply the result of inexperience.

"With everybody being new, there were some communication issues, and we messed up some of the plays, which, unless you were out on the field, you wouldn't know about," Decker admitted. "That's just gonna come from guys being more comfortable. Once we're all communicating and we all know what we're doing—even if we're wrong—if we're all the same page, it usually works out."

Of course it’s also possible that talent—and not experience—is the OSU offensive line’s primary issue.

Whereas last year’s unit featured three players who currently find themselves on NFL rosters in Jack Mewhort (Indianapolis Colts), Corey Linsley (Green Bay Packers) and Andrew Norwell (Carolina Panthers), this year’s includes a converted defensive lineman redshirt freshman in Billy Price, a fifth-year senior seeing the first significant snaps of his career in Darryl Baldwin and an undersized center in Jacoby Boren.

Only Decker and right guard Pat Elflein appear to have solidified their spots in the starting lineup, with the latter enduring struggles of his own against the Midshipmen.

Of course, as Decker learned a year ago, one week can make all the difference when it comes to one’s outlook on the season. After being dominated by Buffalo’s Khalil Mack in his first game as a starter in the Buckeyes’ 2013 opener, Decker put together a strong sophomore season, which resulted in him entering 2014 as the OSU offensive line’s anchor.

The unit’s de facto leader Decker wouldn’t be shocked to see his group take a quick step in the right direction, similar to the one that he enjoyed last season.

“You finally realize what the game environment is like,” Decker said. “The biggest improvement, I think, is from Game 1 to 2. I expect to see a lot of improvement.”

Meyer—and Barrett—certainly hope that Decker’s right. This weekend—and this season—will depend on it.


Ben Axelrod is Bleacher Report's Ohio State Lead Writer. You can follow him on Twitter @BenAxelrod. Unless noted otherwise, all quotes were obtained firsthand. All recruiting information courtesy of 247Sports.

Read more College Football news on

Predicting College Football QBs Most Likely to Transfer Next

Although college football players don't get paid, there is still a big pile of cash on the line for those suffering under amateur status.

For many, it’s a deferred payment scheme—play well now, get drafted later and watch the money flow in.

It’s why so many players—especially those at skill positions where starting spots are limited—transfer schools during their college careers.  It’s a growing trend that reflects two interwoven pillars of today’s game: coverage saturation and perceived financial potential.

In other words, if a guy really is as good as his hype—think star ratings, recruiting battles, overwhelming media attention—then why isn’t he in a starting role, auditioning for his place in the pros?

The position where this is most visible is at quarterback. Now, more players are switching schools and repositioning themselves to where they can cash in on the star power they garnered as high school recruits.

Here’s a look around the country at the young quarterbacks who may move next. The list ranges from highly touted guys stuck in a backup role to players who have already moved down in an effort to move back up.

Though all the situations are unique, they share one common denominator: In the blink of an eye, an injury or dip in performance changes everything.

Begin Slideshow

Georgia Football: Report Card Grades for Every New Starter

The Georgia Bulldogs came away with a big win last Saturday, as they ran past the Clemson Tigers in the season opener. The first half was evenly played by both teams, but with the help of the running game, led by Todd Gurley, the Bulldogs were able to dominate the second half.

But credit has to go to the new starters. Though Gurley may have been the standout player, guys such as Aaron Davis, Mike Thornton and Greg Pyke played a key role in the win.

So here are report card grades for every new starter.

Begin Slideshow

College Football: Week 1 Recap, Pick Results and Final Thought

The opening weekend of the 2014 season lived up to the hype with entertaining matchups that saw No. 1 and No. 2 almost go down, as well as a surprising blowout and an impressive comeback. 

Reining national champion Florida State got all it could handle against an aggressive Oklahoma State squad, which continued to battle back until it couldn’t anymore, in a close 37-31 contest. Despite Jameis Winston throwing two interceptions, his 28-yard touchdown run at the end of the third quarter and a 50-yard strike to Rashad Greene with 3:58 left in the fourth quarter proved to be the difference in the ‘Noles pulling off a big non-conference win. 

While Florida State had to hold on for dear life in Arlington, the No. 2-ranked team in the country found itself in a tussle as well. Alabama, who decided to go with senior Blake Sims under center, got more than expected against a Dana Holgorsen team that won only four games last season. West Virginia starting quarterback Clint Trickett passed for 365 yards and one touchdown, but there was an unexpected hero in Crimson Tide sophomore placekicker Adam Griffith, who accounted for 15 points and kicked three of four field goals from 40-plus yards. Alabama managed to escape the Georgia Dome with a 33-23 victory. 

The biggest surprise of Week 1, occurred Thursday evening when Texas A&M traveled to South Carolina, in what was supposed to be an uphill battle for a Johnny Manziel-less Aggie team. Not only did Kevin Sumlin’s squad come in ready to play, it put on a dominating performance that will be remembered in years to come. Sophomore quarterback Kenny Hill broke Manziel’s single-game passing record with 511 yards. He also threw three touchdowns in Texas A&M’s 52-28 route over South Carolina. 

Down in Houston Saturday night, Wisconsin appeared to be in full control of the game with a 24-7 lead early in the third quarter. Two field goals by LSU kicker Colby Delahoussaye in the third quarter chipped into the the Badger lead. Once the fourth quarter started, it was all Tigers.

An Anthony Jennings 36-yard touchdown pass to John Diarse, followed by a two-point conversion put the game at 24-21 with 12:08 left. Almost three minutes later, Kenny Hilliard’s 28-yard rushing touchdown put LSU up for good. With an impressive 28-24 win, where Les Miles’ group scored 17 unanswered points, they now put themselves in the College Football Playoff race. 

Speaking of the College Football Playoff race, Georgia may have already put itself in the discussion as a top-four team. Toddy Gurley’s dominating career-high performance of 198 yards and four touchdowns, including a 100-yard kickoff return, helped the Dawgs knock off Clemson 45-21. 

Other games to mention include three-time FCS Champion North Dakota State defeating a fifth straight FBS opponent in Iowa State 34-14 with a solid performance from running back John Crockett (17 carries, 139 yards, three TDs), along with No. 5 Ohio State getting by Navy 34-17 without Braxton Miller and No. 7 UCLA sneaking by Virginia 28-20 on the road. 


Pick Results

Overall Record: 4-1

Note: Team in bold indicates author’s pick


Prediction: Alabama 38, West Virginia 17

Result: Alabama 33, West Virginia 23


Prediction: Georgia 35, Clemson 24

Result: Georgia 45, Clemson 21


Prediction: Florida State 38, Oklahoma State 16

Result: Florida State 37, Oklahoma State 31


Prediction: LSU 37, Wisconsin 30

Result: LSU 28, Wisconsin 24


Prediction: Miami (Fla) 26, Louisville 24

Result: Louisville 31, Miami (Fla) 13 


Final Thought: 

The nation knew heading into the 2014 season that junior Georgia running back Todd Gurley was good. On Saturday night though, he hit a whole new level with 198 yards and four touchdowns. His 100-yard kickoff return in the second quarter was impressive, but his performance in the fourth quarter to put Clemson away made Fantasy Football managers wish they could draft him already. If Gurley continues to rack up yards and touchdowns like he is capable of this season, there is no doubt he will be in New York City at the Heisman Trophy Presentation on December 13. 

Not only is Gurley likely the best back in the country, his team has the potential to be an SEC and national title contender. 

A road trip to division rival South Carolina on Sept. 13 could be the difference in advancing to the SEC title game or not.  

Read more College Football news on

Michigan Wolverines vs. Notre Dame Fighting Irish Complete Game Preview

Michigan spanked Appalachian State 52-14 in its season opener but faces a more difficult test on the road this week versus historic rival Notre Dame. This is the last scheduled meeting for these programs, and each wants to go out with a win. Because of a scheduling quirk, Michigan plays all three of its rivalry games on the road this season—and this game looks to be the most manageable. A loss to the Fighting Irish, and Brady Hoke and his Michigan Men might be looking at a long season.

Date: Saturday, September 6, 2014

Time: 7:30 p.m. EDT

Place: Notre Dame Stadium (80,795), South Bend, Ind.

Series vs. Notre Dame: Michigan leads 24-16-1

Television: NBC

Radio:Michigan Sports Network

Spread: Michigan (+5), via

Live GameTracker

Last Meeting vs. Notre Dame: Michigan 41, Notre Dame 30.

*Information according to University of Michigan Wolverines game notes.

Begin Slideshow

Miami vs. Louisville: Game Grades, Analysis for the Hurricanes and Cardinals

Despite the fact that Louisville's best receiver, DeVante Parker, was sitting on the sideline, the Miami Hurricanes were overpowered in a 31-13 loss to the Cardinals.

Some players had noteworthy individual performances, but how did collective units perform during the final game of Week 1?

Pass Offense

True freshman Brad Kaaya looked decent in his college debut for Miami. He displayed adequate power, accuracy and touch while progressing through reads quite smoothly. Kaaya showed he can be a really special quarterback, but inexperience was an overwhelming factor.


Run Offense

Great things were expected from Duke Johnson, but the Miami offensive line didn't help out its highly touted running back. Taylor Gadbois was dominated by Lorenzo Mauldin, and Danny Isidora wasn't reliable, contributing to a team average of only 2.6 yards per carry.

Pass Defense

Though Parker was sidelined, it didn't matter for Will Gardner and Louisville. Zone defense often stung the Hurricanes, and the team left open receivers in vacated spaces for catches that resulted in first downs.

Granted, Anthony Chickillo, Denzel Perryman and Ufomba Kamalu each tallied one sack.


Run Defense

Plain and simple, Perryman was a tank. However, the senior linebacker cannot do it alone. The Miami defensive linemen definitely improved at shedding blocks and entering the backfield, but they still missed chances to register important tackles for loss.

Special Teams

Matt Goudis nailed both 24-yard field goals he attempted, and summer transfer Justin Vogel averaged 46.8 yards per punt.

For some bizarre reason, Stacy Coley fielded a punt at the one-yard line. Other than that mistake, he was one tackle away from breaking a long return on two different kicks. Plus, the sophomore had a stellar punt return negated by an illegal block in the back.



This was a forgettable game for the Miami coaching staff. Al Golden, who doubles as the special teams coordinator, was not thrilled after a kick-return touchdown. Defensive coordinator Mark D'Onofrio made some questionable decisions, such as putting five men in the box in obvious running situations.

But the biggest negative of the day was offensive coordinator James Coley. The Hurricanes threw five screen passes that gained fewer than 10 total yards, and they consistently attempted to run through a surprisingly stout Louisville defensive line.


Pass Offense

While replacing Teddy Bridgewater is not an enviable task, Gardner showed he is capable of picking up much of the slack. Yes, his two fumbles should have turned into 14 Miami points, but Gardner was saved by a dropped lateral and tough defense from his teammates.

The sophomore completed 20 of 28 passes for 206 yards and two touchdowns, finding eight different receivers on the night.


Run Offense

Dominique Brown was a major factor in running out the clock and sealing the victory for the Cardinals. The senior scampered for 143 yards and one touchdown, accounting for eight first downs with his legs.

Then again, despite all the success Louisville appeared to have on the ground, it still managed just 3.0 yards per attempt.

Pass Defense

Louisville silenced the Hurricanes' overused screen game and their playmakers, limiting Coley to three receptions for nine yards. Additionally, 59 of Kaaya's 174 passing yards came on the final drive, and he tossed two interceptions.

Overall, Miami made a single reception between the hashmarks, so the Cardinals effectively contained a work-in-progress air attack.


Run Defense

Holding Johnson to 4.5 yards per carry is enough of an achievement anyway, but Louisville left no doubt which team won the battle of the trenches.

Not including his 32 yards on back-to-back carries, Johnson was held to a mere 3.2 yards per attempt. That is a fantastic—and extremely unexpected—mark by by the Cardinals.


Special Teams

Speedster Corvin Lamb returned a kickoff 97 yards for a touchdown, giving his team a lead it never relinquished. John Wallace connected on four extra points and a 28-yard field goal, and punter Ryan Johnson recorded 44.4 yards per kick.


Perhaps the Cardinals' coaches looked better due to the ineptitude of Miami's, but the Louisville staff consistently had its athletes in the proper positions to succeed.

The two most glaring mistakes were completely player error, so Bobby Petrino's return to the program was satisfactory.


Follow Bleacher Report college football writer David Kenyon on Twitter: @Kenyon19_BR.

Read more College Football news on

Pac-12 Football: 8 Head-to-Head Matchups to Watch for in Week 2

With Week 1 of the Pac-12 football season in the books, it's time to gaze ahead at a Week 2 slate that, while mild on the whole, contains two monster matchups that could have major implications in the four-team College Football Playoff at the conclusion of the season.

There are some intriguing games to watch outside of USC-Stanford and Oregon-Michigan State, but these two contests will dominate our discussion considering the four squads each have the talent to stay among the title contenders throughout the year.

Texas-San Antonio-Arizona could bring some drama after the Roadrunners blasted Houston 27-7, and Washington better be ready for Eastern Washington after slipping past Hawaii, 17-16.

But out of all the games, which individual matchups are you most excited about? Which player performances will we be talking about in the offseason?

Take a look at eight head-to-head matchups to watch for in Week 2.

Begin Slideshow

Miami vs. Louisville: Score and Twitter Reaction

A unique Labor Day college football game pitted the Louisville Cardinals against the Miami (Florida) Hurricanes. After the Cardinals beat Miami 36-9 in last year's Russell Athletic Bowl, the Hurricanes were again dominated on Monday, 31-13, at Papa John's Cardinal Stadium.

Beating Louisville at home with coach Bobby Petrino at the helm is a tall task, as ESPN Stats & Info pointed out:

Both teams were starting freshman quarterbacks—Louisville's redshirt signal-caller Will Gardner and Miami's true first-year passer Brad Kaaya. Gardner was without his No. 1 receiving target in DeVante Parker, yet he showed superior poise and was more proficient than his overwhelmed counterpart.

Gardner, who went 20-of-28 for 206 yards with two touchdowns, also had the benefit of a superior running game, courtesy of Dominique Brown's 143 yards on 33 carries.

The Cardinals shut down Miami running back Duke Johnson for the most part. Johnson is one of the most explosive playmakers in college football, yet he had little room to run versus Louisville's front seven. He amassed just 69 yards on his first 19 carries—and that included a 24-yard scamper.

Omar Kelly of the Sun Sentinel lamented the tactics deployed by Miami's coaching staff:

Johnson didn't get going until the fourth quarter after the Hurricanes turned it over on downs, following a decent drive into Louisville territory. This included a long reception from Johnson negated by a penalty.

Former Louisville safety and current New York Jet Calvin Pryor was attuned to what the talented Johnson was doing:

The big momentum changer came earlier on special teams, when Louisville's Corvin Lamb took a kickoff 97 yards to the house with 4:37 remaining in the first half. It came just after Kaaya's best drive of the night—a nine-play, 88-yard jaunt that ended in three points and a 10-7 Hurricanes lead.

Then Miami found itself suddenly down and dejected from Lamb's playmaking in the return game. Adding insult to injury, Lamb was a product of the opposition's stomping grounds.'s Andrea Adelson supplied this keen bit of information:

As was the case in their last encounter with the Cardinals, the Hurricanes were unable to convert third-down opportunities. Miami missed in all 11 third-down situations in the Russell Athletic Bowl and missed on its first nine Monday evening.

Kaaya finally came through with a completion late in the third quarter, but it offered little consolation after such a terrible stretch of execution. On the very next play, a bad Kaaya throw was well behind his intended target and picked off by James Sample.

Maybe this is some consolation for Hurricanes fans from ESPN's Colin Cowherd:

An inauspicious three-and-out to start the game preceded Gardner's exceptional first touchdown drive in place of departed star QB Teddy Bridgewater. Gardner completed all five passes on the march, hitting freshman tight end Charles Standberry for a two-yard TD strike.

Although Kaaya would respond with a two-yard scoring toss of his own in the second quarter, he was badly outplayed by Gardner otherwise, posting a final line of 17-of-29 passing for 174 yards and two interceptions.

Kirk Herbstreit of ESPN empathized with Kaaya:

That doesn't mean the Hurricanes couldn't have found a way to claw back into the game, though. A couple of gift-wrapped turnovers generated chances to score. They just weren't taken advantage of.

Jason McIntyre of The Big Lead was critical of how Miami squandered golden opportunities to capitalize on turnovers with little ground to cover before paydirt:

Brown wore down the Hurricanes defense throughout, and when he scored a 15-yard TD to extend the lead to 21-13 late in the third,'s Howie Lindsey compared Brown favorably to another physical Cardinals ball-carrier:

On Gardner's second TD pass of the night, Brown threw a great block after the play-action fake, as Gerald Christian hauled in the 10-yard strike with just 1:43 left in the game.

Petrino's return to the Louisville sidelines went smoothly enough, and he was excited to get the year underway with a high-profile game off the bat.

"I've always enjoyed opening with a game that had a lot at stake," said Petrino, per The Courier-Journal's Jeff Greer. "It really helps you in the offseason. It helps you with your motivation in the winter and getting up early for your workouts. It's a great opening for us. Our players are excited about it."

Louisville Football noted just how much fanfare followed the Cardinals to Monday's game:

This reaction from the New York Post's Brian Costello summarizes the probable sentiments in South Beach:

Hurricanes coach Al Golden was bold to start the untested Kaaya over fifth-year senior Jake Heaps. Based on how bad the offense looked Monday, perhaps Golden will turn to the more seasoned signal-caller in Heaps before handing the keys to Kaaya for good.

This is a momentous victory for Louisville against a traditionally quality opponent. The Cardinals needed a positive start to their inaugural season in the ACC, and they got it. In the process, they saw their young QB, Gardner, overcome the loss of his best receiver.

It was enough to suggest Louisville's offense can survive without Parker for the time being.

It will be interesting to see whether Miami keeps Kaaya in for what could be a confidence booster at home against Florida A&M. Meanwhile, Louisville remains at home and will improve to 2-0 versus Murray State on Saturday, barring an unbelievable upset.

Read more College Football news on

Recruiting Offers of the Week

One week after landing 3-star California offensive lineman Dru Samia, the Oklahoma Sooners doubled down in the Golden State by offering a pair of 2015 standouts in 4-star receiver Ykili Ross and 4-star linebacker Khaylan Thomas

The 6’2”, 185-pound Ross is a U.S. Army All-American with offers from powerhouses such as Notre Dame, UCLA, Oregon and Texas A&M among others.

Thomas, a 6’2”, 210-pound outside linebacker, holds offers from the likes of Arizona, Arizona State, UCLA and Miami among others.

The fact that Bob Stoops and his staff are active in California is not a new phenomenon.

As Jason Kersey of The Oklahoman described, the Sooners began to make a dent in the Golden State with a 2010 class that included future standouts such as Brennan Clay, Tony Jefferson and Kenny Stills.

“I think a lot of things,” Stoops said to Kersey. “Success, you know, the championships we've been in and won, and not won. And I think they pay attention and see a lot of the success California kids have had coming out here. I think it all goes together. And the fact that we're on TV every week.”

Oklahoma currently has 11 commitments in the 2015 cycle, with its class modestly rated at No. 31 nationally and third among Big 12 schools in 247Sports' team rankings.

If Stoops is able to land a few more West Coast blue-chippers, expect the Sooners to make a run at landing the Big 12’s top class.


Stanford Offers Trio of 2016 4-Star Standouts

Things have started slowly for David Shaw and Stanford in the 2015 cycle, but it appears that the Cardinal are turning up the heat on some of the nation’s top juniors.

The biggest offer was made to in-state 5-star linebacker Caleb Kelly, whose Crystal Ball is currently reflecting the Sooners as his favorite, according to Justin Hopkins of 247Sports.

Texas 4-star wide receiver Devin Duvernay also picked up an offer from Stanford. The 5’11”, 185-pounder is the No. 38 player overall and the No. 5 wide receiver in the 2016 class. Duvernay has offers from powers such as Texas, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, Alabama and Auburn, among numerous others. 

Finally, per Paul Strelow of TigerIllustrated, the Cardinal offered 4-star corner Tennessee native Nygel Edmonds. Tennessee, Vanderbilt, Clemson, Duke and Virginia Tech are among the schools who have offered the 5’11”, 181-pounder.


Ohio State Offers a Pair of 2016 Studs

Ohio State is the newest offer for 4-star corner Damar Hamlin

The Buckeyes represent the fourth offer for the 6’0”, 175-pound Pittsburgh product. Penn State, Pittsburgh and Temple are his other three offers.

Hamlin camped at both Penn State and Ohio State in July, and he’s currently rated as the nation’s No. 12 corner in the 2016 class.

Urban Meyer also tendered an offer to 4-star North Carolina wide receiver Divine Deablo. The Buckeyes join Clemson, North Carolina, South Carolina and Georgia as a group of powers trying to land Deablo.


Alabama Offers 2015 Texas RB Commit

With T.J. Yeldon a potential candidate to turn pro after this season and the likely emergence of sophomore running back Derrick Henry this fall, a strong possibility exists that Nick Saban and his staff will look to use one of the last few 2015 scholarships available on a quality back. 

The Tide offered 3-star Texas commitment Tristian Houston last week.

Alabama already has one back committed in 4-star in-state standout Desherrius Flowers, and they are in the running for 4-star Florida native Jacques Patrick.

While pulling Houston away from Texas and landing Patrick over favorite Florida State would be upsets, the Tide may still be active in searching for another running back to complement Flowers in the 2015 class.


2016 Florida CB Saivion Smith Blowing Up

Miami and Tennessee are the latest schools to offer 2016 4-star corner Saivion Smith.

The 6’1”, 175-pounder is rated as the No. 60 overall prospect in the 2016 class and the sixth-best corner. 

Smith holds offers from Florida State, Florida, UCLA, Clemson and Ohio State, among others. 

The IMG Academy standout attended a summer camp at Florida and came away impressed, according to GatorBait’s Luke Stampini (subscription required). 

"I did a camp and then I did an unofficial visit after," Smith said. "It's real nice. Most schools are spread out. I like how the school is. All the athletes have easy access to all the classrooms, the dorms aren't spread out real far."


Best of the Rest


Sanjay Kirpalani is a National Recruiting Analyst for Bleacher Report. Unless otherwise noted, all recruiting information courtesy of 247Sports.

Read more College Football news on

Louisville's Corvin Lamb Returns Kickoff 97 Yards for a TD vs. Miami

Louisville and Miami (Florida) squared off on Labor Day in Kentucky, and Cardinals running back Corvin Lamb made a statement with a 97-yard kickoff return for a touchdown. 

The huge second-quarter run put the Cardinals up 14-10 over the Hurricanes.

[SB Nation]

Read more College Football news on

David Ash, Dominic Espinosa Injuries Force Charlie Strong to Adjust, Again

The entire narrative around the Texas football program changed Monday when head coach Charlie Strong announced the injuries to two key contributors on the Texas offense.

Redshirt junior quarterback David Ash suffered a head injury against North Texas last Saturday and will miss the BYU game on Sept. 6.

According to Strong, Ash believes the injury occurred on the first contact he faced in the first quarter, but he did not begin experiencing symptoms until after Saturday's game.

This injury is nothing new for the redshirt junior quarterback. Ash suffered a concussion against BYU last season, returned to the field two weeks later, only to have recurring concussion symptoms and was sidelined for the remainder of the season.

Strong does not know if Ash will miss more than one game.

But Ash's injury was just a portion of the bad news Strong delivered Monday.

Senior center Dominic Espinosa—who left Saturday's game with an injury—will undergo surgery Wednesday to repair a broken right ankle. No timetable has been set for his return.


Constant Adjustments

Strong has only been in Austin for eight months, but it probably seems like an eternity for the head coach. 

Whether it was getting adjusted to the extra attention or added pressure of public speaking, going on a 12-city publicity tour across the state of Texas or dismissing seven players for violating his rules, Strong's short career at Texas has not been a breeze. 

The injuries to Ash and Espinosa is just another hiccup for the first-year head coach.

Losing a starting quarterback is a difficult blow for any team to overcome. Replacing a starter with a quarterback who's game experience primarily includes garbage-time play is even worse.

But that's the reality for the Texas offense.

The Longhorns will rely on sophomore Tyrone Swoopes to lead the charge against BYU Saturday.

Nobody truly knows what Swoopes is capable of doing at the college level because of his lack of playing time. And kneeling on the ball to run out the clock in the Longhorns game versus North Texas hardly counts as game experience.

The Longhorns' ground game will need to be utilized more than ever with the inexperienced quarterback under center.

Senior Malcolm Brown and junior Johnathan Gray are two of the best one-two punches in the Big 12, and the pressure will be on both running backs to carry the Texas offense moving forward.

But opening up holes to allow the duo to run wild will be a greater task without Espinosa.

The fifth-year senior has 40 career starts for the Longhorns. His backup, redshirt freshman Jake Raulerson, has yet to start a game.

Espinosa's experience is impossible to replace on the offensive line, which is one of the least seasoned position groups on the team.


Time to Step Up

One could argue losing Espinosa is just as big of a blow as losing Ash.

Throughout the offseason, Strong has constantly said he does not need Ash to carry the offense. In fact, the head coach specifically told the quarterback that all he truly needs him to be is a game manager.

But the reasons why Strong did not need Ash to be outstanding was because of the talent Texas has at running back and the leadership the offense had with Espinosa at the helm.

Strong needs his players to step up and help the team move forward with Ash and Espinosa's futures unknown.

"We have a football team, and we have to go play," Strong said. "Other players have to step up and other players have to go play. It's no different. Now the challenge of this football team is how well we can bounce back and what we're all about."

One positive note for the offensive line is senior Desmond Harrison, who was suspended for the first game of the season after violating team rules, will return to the team for the BYU game, per Wescott Eberts of SB Nation (via Yahoo Sports).

Many Texas players and coaches mentioned Harrison as one of the best players on the offensive line throughout fall camp. And senior defensive end Cedric Reed—whom ESPN's Mel Kiper Jr. has listed as the No. 1 senior DE for the 2015 NFL draft—said Harrison is one of the toughest opponents to face.

The 6'8", 313-pound senior needs to play up to his potential to protect Swoopes and block for the Longhorns' run game.


Tough Road Ahead

Much of the offense's success is dependent on offensive line coach Joe Wickline's ability to find the right group to help the ground game. And he will need to find that solution as soon as possible as the Longhorns prepare to face some of the toughest opponents on its schedule in the coming weeks.

The next opponent on the schedule is the same team that embarrassed Texas last season and ultimately cost the job of former defensive coordinator Manny Diaz. BYU is coming off of a road victory against UConn, which saw the Cougars defense hold its opponent's offense to only 74 rushing yards.

But BYU is only the first hurdle the Longhorns will need to overcome over the next few weeks. 

Strong's job got a lot tougher following the 38-7 blowout over North Texas. And the damages from Saturday's win could very well impact the Longhorns' success for the rest of the season.


Unless otherwise noted, all quotes were obtained firsthand.

Taylor Gaspar is Bleacher Report's featured columnist covering the Texas Longhorns. Follow her on Twitter: @Taylor_Gaspar.

Read more College Football news on

Oregon Ducks vs. Michigan State Spartans Complete Game Preview

On Saturday in Eugene, Oregon a team will claim an inside track to the first ever College Football Playoff. Pac-12 powerhouse Oregon will host Big-10 co-favorite Michigan State in a battle of Top 10 programs.

Let's just call it flash versus smash. 

Oregon, currently ranked third in the country according to the Associated Press, comes in fresh off a 62-13 blowout over South Dakota. Michigan State, the defending Rose Bowl champion, is ranked eighth in the country and took down Jacksonville State 45-7 this past weekend. 

The Ducks come in featuring one of the best offenses in college football. The offense ranked second in the nation in total yards in 2013 and third in points per game. Meanwhile, the Spartans defense was ranked third in the country last season in points per game and second in total yards.

It’s a clash of clashes and should be treated as such. ESPN’s College Gameday will be broadcasting from the University of Oregon campus on Saturday morning. This will be the sixth consecutive year that the program has taken its talents to Eugene, though it will be the first featuring Oregon and a non-Pac-12 opponent. 

In terms of the actual game, here’s what you need to know:

Date: Saturday, Sept. 6th

Time: 3:30 p.m. PT

Place: Autzen Stadium (Eugene, OR)


Spread: Oregon -11 according to

Begin Slideshow